Jumping back to this real quick, Jenara was in my own opinion much stronger as a commander back when commander tuck was a thing. Jenara didn't require her deck to be built around her at all so she was a standalone wincon so if she was tucked, none of your deck was really dead draws and likewise a win from the deck didn't require her. When tuck was a thing, blue and white had probably the best selection of tuck effects so we got to run a LOT of tuck and our access to green also let us toolbox and pull her out of tuck if we wanted.ZenN wrote: ↑3 years ago@SaintForthigan Thanks!
My switch to Derevi, Empyrial Tactician from Jenara, Asura of War was motivated by a few things. Off the top of my head:Overall, I've definitely been happier with Derevi than I was with Jenara. I do occasionally miss the ability to beat down with her, but the trade-off is easily worth it to me. I totally get what you're saying about not necessarily having a good use for the extra mana you can produce, but it just might be a matter of needing to play a few more mana sinks, or tutor for the mana sinks you do have more aggressively. I usually find a good use for all the extra untaps, even if it's just as simple as multiple uses of Gavony Township per turn cycle.
- It came to a point where Jenara wins were getting rarer and rarer, as people in my group were ready for me to go for a pumped Jenara win later in the game and often had an answer.
- Beyond the ability to beat face, Jenara just didn't offer much utility.
- Derevi allows for huge mana advantages, pseudo-vigilance, tap/untap shenanigans, surprise blocks, surprise taps (especially useful against a frend's Thraximundar deck), etc etc.
- Derevi's combat trigger ability pairs very nicely with a deck full of a lot of 1 and 2 power creatures that I usually don't mind throwing away.
- If you aggressively tutor for Birthing Pod, having constant access to a 3 CMC creature to Pod away without stacking up obscene commander tax is lovely.
The loss of commander tuck was a healthy thing for this format, but it was probably also a bad thing for Jenara, Asura of War as a commander. It was one of the better commanders to use tuck with and it was weaker against her.
I didn't mean to hijack I just thought I would contribute my own $0.02 to the matter. I was on the decline of playing my Jenara when the tuck change happened and in retrospect I can see how much that might have hurt her.