Vote: OneAndOnly, void_nothing Saint Cherlia, Evercaring 1GW Legendary Creature - Elf Cleric (R) Lifelink When Saint Cherlia enters the battlefield and at the beginning of your upkeep, put a hexproof counter and an indestructible counter on another target creature you control with base power and/or ...

Vote: Lorn Asbord Schutta, void_nothing

There's a bit of rhyme going on with that flavor text I've notices, but I'm fairly certain the word you want is "foils", not "fails". No, I do mean fails. In fact, I fail to see how foils would work there at all. Even those sworn to keep the living from the dead have a price. On...

I have finished my April MCC Round 1 judgments.

All done. It seems 5 will be advancing from my pool. EDIT: It was pointed to me that a part of one my critiques was left blank. This had no impact on the score; I know exactly why it ended up blank. EDIT 2: I have had to make an impactful score change, reducing the number of advancing players to 5. ...

Vote: klutzedufus, void_nothing Sosvu'nal, the Whispers 5U{U/B}B Legendary Creature - Horror (M) Sosvu'nal has protection from players with three or fewer cards in hand. Forecast - 2UB , Reveal Sosvu'nal, the Whispers from your hand: Each player discards two cards, then each player draws a card. Whi...

Vote: klutzedufus, LandellXil0cent Valiant Smuggler 1W Creature - Human Rogue (U) Vigilance W, T : Return another target nonland permanent you control to its owner's hand. Last gasp W (You may pay the last gasp cost and exile this card from your graveyard to activate one of its abilities.) 1/3 IIW: ...

Vote: shullz, netn10

Blood Burst BR
Instant (U)
Destroy target nonland, nonartifact, nonenchantment creature. Create a Blood token, plus an additional Blood token if that creature's toughness was 4 or greater.
A Voldaren party isn't complete without a spectacle.

IIW: Affinity

Vote: JovialJovian, netn10 Mistwing Drake 3U Creature - Drake (C) Flying T : Target creature without flying gets -4/-0 until end of turn. Activate as a sorcery. Last gasp U (You may pay the last gasp cost and exile this card from your graveyard to activate one of its abilities.) 2/2 IIW: Last gasp (...

Ugin is probably going to get involved, but on which side?

Vote: JovialJovian, netn10 Saint's Binding 2WW Enchantment (U) At the beginning of your upkeep, choose one. If you have half or less of your starting life total, choose both- -Return each card exiled with Saint's Binding to the battlefield under its owner's control, then exile target nonland permane...

For Hint #5, I have a feeling it might be Cultural Exchange. Plenty of more well known options though, like Traumatize

Vote: JovialJovian, void_nothing Vannak, the Overchime 2UR Legendary Artifact Creature - Weird (R) If a triggered ability of a permanent would trigger for the first time this turn, instead you scry 1, then put a charge counter on Vannak. Remove X charge counters from Vannak: Vannak gets +X/+X until ...

I don't mind judging another month

@Ink-Treader I disagree about Balance Your strike against the submission is how problematic it is to achieve the solved condition. In commander, any kind of wheel effect that includes opponents will suffice. Temple Bell activation and a single card already exiled with an enchantment before, whether...

My March MCC Round 4 judgments are finished. Any questions about your own card's judgments can be asked here, any questions about another player should be done by PM.

Alright, I think I'm satisfied. Design (2/3) Appeal - I don't believe Timmy would be interested in this. Johnny, however, is enthralled . Spike also likes the nuances of this, though they will be watching what Johnny gets up to with great interest. (1.5/3) Elegance - That replacement effect is crazy...

My March Round 3 judgments are done.

I did think I might have caught something that may have made this a more standard 3 person finals, but considered that it does have functional purpose, so 4 way final it (potentially) is!

I am content with my judgments; consider them finished. Design (2.5/3) Appeal - Certainly fun for Timmy. Rather blunt for Johnny, though there is some potential. Spike finds it fairly agreeable, though they might prefer Threaten , but there's definitely room to play this cleverly, or Overload when t...

My March MCC Round 2 judgments are also finished.

And done! Design (2.5/3) Appeal - Timmy will find this pretty fun, as will Johnny. Spike isn't as sold, but there's plenty of potential. (2/3) Elegance - This card relies heavily on the somewhat obscure rules knowledge that Auras entering the battlefield without a target enter attached to something ...

My March MCC Round 1 judgments are finished.

Vote: TessaMTG, void_nothing

Grave Wrath
B Enchantment - Aura (R)
Enchant creature
If you control enchanted creature it gets +X/+X, where X is the number of creature cards in your graveyard. Otherwise it gets -X/-X.
Unearth 1B
Transmute 2B

IIW: Board wipes

And finished Design (2.5/3) Appeal - I think Timmy likes this just fine as 4/5 of stats for 4, and a potent way to dump mana. Not too much for Johnny, but there's angles. It is efficient enough for Spike in stats, and the extra G to get the 'bite' effect feels reasonable. (3/3) Elegance - Seems eleg...

Vote: Komandon, void_nothing

Mana Instability 2BRG
Sorcery (R)
Destroy all permanents with mana abilities.

IIW: Low mana value, big numbers