The CCL Discussion Thread

[void_nothing]

Well, first off, "mill", "discard", "tap", and others are keyword actions rather than keywords, and more than that, they're essentially evergreen - in fact, they appear more than most evergreen keywords do.

As stated in the thread, I've listed all of the valid choices of keywords to use in the clarifications.

[Raptorchan]

Just to inform you: this challenge includes consecutive mana VALUES, not costs. The original post is fixed.

[Raptorchan]

January CCL poll is up.

[Raptorchan]

@OneAndOnly @shullz as far as I know, "above" means "higher than you in the list", not lower.

[shullz]

@OneAndOnly @shullz as far as I know, "above" means "higher than you in the list", not lower.

You're right. I just did the same thing as last time. I'll change it.

[OneAndOnly]

I just decided what they hey, I'll critique everyone's submittals. I only ranked the six above me, and only top-three'd the ones I thought were top-three worthy.

[Raptorchan]

One day left to vote in January Final Poll.

[Raptorchan]

@void_nothing wins the January CCL!

[void_nothing]

February CCL top 4 and March CCL round 1 will both come tomorrow. Time has gotten away from me.

[Komandon]

Can the tokens generated for the CCL 1/1 real world animals be more than one kind. Such as an animal version of Sarpadian Empires, Vol. VII or A Killer Among Us (I'm not planing on that kind of card. I have something else in mind.)

[void_nothing]

Can the tokens generated for the CCL 1/1 real world animals be more than one kind. Such as an animal version of Sarpadian Empires, Vol. VII or A Killer Among Us (I'm not planing on that kind of card. I have something else in mind.)

Yes, that fits the challenge just fine.

[void_nothing]

Now putting out the call for a host for the April CCL!

[AnotherAlias]

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3?

[void_nothing]

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3?

No, absolutely not. The brackets are there to determine who can score points from whom and give everyone a shot.

[AnotherAlias]

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3?

No, absolutely not. The brackets are there to determine who can score points from whom and give everyone a shot.

Thank you. That's what I thought, but it's good to have confirmation before I call out another user.

@marioguy3, as void_nothing stated above, you cannot have Komandon in your top 3 for round 2. (Those above you on the list (looping to the bottom) were: netn10, shullz, Raptorchan, OneAndOnly, Henlock, and AnotherAlias.)

[Lorn Asbord Schutta]

Now putting out the call for a host for the April CCL!

And I will heed, if I am allowed to.

[void_nothing]

Now putting out the call for a host for the April CCL!

And I will heed, if I am allowed to.

More than that, you're welcome to. It's good to have you back and I'll put your name down.

[marioguy3]

@AnotherAlias Thank you for mentioning that. True mistake. Fixed.

[AnotherAlias]

@Komandon, same thing applies to you. You cannot have me in your top 3 because I was not one of the six above you. (Your list was meant to be: marioguy3, netn10, shullz, Raptorchan, OneAndOnly, and Henlock.)

[Komandon]

@AnotherAlias I see I looped wrong. I skipped Henlock by accident and did you who is below me.

I'm going to remove my post with a place holder and cut/paste in a note file on my phone for now.

[void_nothing]

Hopefully the confusion about first and second round judging has now been cleared up. Remember that you should always evaluate the contestants below you on the list for round 1 and above you on the list for round 2! On that note, I'll be posting the next round of the March CCL tomorrow - sorry for the delay on my end.

[marioguy3]

@Raptorchan Congratulations on the win in February!

[Henlock]

Quick question: Does a permanent that returns itself count for the challenge?

[void_nothing]

Quick question: Does a permanent that returns itself count for the challenge?

I'll say yes it does.

[AnotherAlias]

@void_nothing, exiling a (permanent) card from a graveyard, then returning that to the battlefield doesn't count, right? Also, does cloaking/manifesting a card in a graveyard count?