Post
by Krishnath » 4 years ago
No time like the present, here's the critiques:
RaikouRider (Ocean Devourer) - Now this feels like a mythic leviathan. I am also happy that it doesn't colorscrew people, by making the target lands islands in *addition* to their other types. Only real difference I would do, would be to up the cost to 4UUU, but that is at most a minor issue.
barbecube (Snowblind Yeti) - Major disconnect between the name and the cards abilities. But the card itself is perfectly fine. Good use of the Snow mana mechanic.
Henlock (Havoc Gang) - It feels like there is a major disconnect between the cards abilities and its flavor. A large creature with Trample wants to be blocked by fewer creatures not more, so it getting menace when large feels very off.
Ink-Treader (Eljagar, the Icetomb) - Now, this card feels legendary, and it is also combolicious which makes it perfect for Commander. It also hits all three of the colors of its color identity. Nothing negative to say about it really.
spacemonaut (Shockwave Elemental) - This card wants to be mythic, it's basically a one shot Mirrorwing Dragon with trample and haste instead of flying. Unless your opponent blocks it, it could be a one sided sweeper. The card feels very, very red, which is perfect.
bravelion83 (Hoarder's Gang) - Feels weird that a rogue is a 4/4, even if it is a whole gang of them. Other than that, the card is fine, although perhaps a little expensive. I feel it wants to cost 3RR as a mythic.
Cardz5000 (Sunderer of Minds) - This card could be perfectly fine as a pure red and black card. Nothing about it seems blue, at all. The power level also seems a bit high for a rare card, I could see it as a mythic for that CC, but as a rare it would cost at least eight mana.
Votes:
#1: Ink-Treader
#2: RaikouRider
#3: spacemonaut
Edit: Forgot a critique, all good now.
Last edited by
Krishnath 4 years ago, edited 2 times in total.
Numquam evolutioni obstes. Solum conculceris.
Pascite draconem, evolvite aut morimini.
The Commander Legacy Project, Come say hello and give your thoughts.
Like to read? Love books and want to recommend one to your fellow forum users?
Go here.