Votes: RattingRots, netn10 ScreenShot---446.png Yes, this is true. Today is my 36th birthday. That inspired me to do a darker riff on Planewide Celebration . Bittersweet Celebration 5WB Sorcery (R) Choose four. You may choose the same mode more than once. • Create a 2/2 white Cat creature token. • R...

Votes: RattingRots, netn10 Rebels' Courage 3GW Enchantment(R) Affinity for tokens (This spell costs 1 less to cast for each token you control.) Creature tokens you control get +1/+1 and have vigilance. Noncreature tokens you control have hexproof. "There is only one way we can do it: all of us,...

Friday 9/27: As a notice to everyone, I don't think I'll be able to finish these now, and I won't be able to do anything tomorrow as I will spend most of my day at the ELD prerelease. I don't think I'll be able to finish these before the very last day (Sunday). Saturday 9/28: Ok, back from the ELD 2...

Of course in the absence of anyone else being able to do it I will step up. If it's not a problem to you, I am more than willing to do it again. I've also already run back to back MCC months before. At least here there's a month in between. I'd be totally willing to step up and post the judge signu...

I've just done it last month, so it's probably better if somebody else does it before I do it again, but if there are no other takers, I'm totally available to make an Eldraine themed month for October.

Votes: shukkets, netn10 Bringer of Sunlight 2W Creature — Human Cleric (U) When Bringer of Sunlight enters the battlefield, exile target creature. If Bringer of Sunlight wasn't evoked, return that creature to the battlefield under its owner's control at the beginning of the next end step. Evoke 4W (...

Votes: slimytrout, marioguy3 I also share RattingRots's question. Adventure Companion 2WW Creature — Human Knight (R) Exiled creature cards that are on an adventure cost 1 less to cast. "Here, let me help you accomplishing your mission. I always help fellow knights in difficulty. After all, loy...

Votes: Krishnath, Rithaniel slimytrout, RattingRots Syr Lenrid, Knight Captain 2RWB Legendary Creature — Human Knight (M) Syr Lenrid, Knight Captain's power and toughness are each equal to the number of Knights you control. Vigilance, trample X , T : Look at the top X cards of your library. You may ...

Votes: Sagharri, Krishnath Adventurous Necromancer 1BB Creature — Human Wizard (U) X , T , Exile Adventurous Necromancer: Choose a creature card in your graveyard that has an adventure. If the Adventure's converted mana cost is X or less, cast that card as an Adventure without paying its mana cost. ...

I still think that it doesn't work as is (*), but I understand your intention. That's very complicated to turn into a functional wording. I don't even know if it's possible. If we were in R&D designing this card for real, I'd advise you to consider different options. I'll let you know if I can t...

Done. First element: Sand (white) Second element: Dust (red) Cloak of Dust 1W Enchantment - Aura (uncommon) Enchant creature Enchanted creature gets +0/+2. If a creature would deal combat damage to enchanted creature, prevent 1 of that damage. Cloak of Sand 1R Enchantment - Aura (uncommon) Enchant c...

Votes: RattingRots, Krishnath

Honorable mention for Sagharri.

To the Adventure! 4G
Sorcery (R)
Search your library for a creature card that has an Adventure. Cast it as an Adventure without paying its mana cost.
Each day is a new adventure.

Votes: Krishnath, Sagharri Now that the full set is known, I'll start tinkering with ELD mechanics too. Venture Wilds Land (U) T : Add C . T : Add one mana of any color. Spend this mana only to cast an Adventure spell or to cast a creature card that's on an adventure. "Who knows what the wilds ...

Votes: netn10, emily Ghost Discharge 2R Instant(U) Phantom R (You may cast this card face down as a 2/2 creature for 3 . Exile it face up any time for its phantom cost, then cast it without paying its mana cost and this spell can't be countered.) Ghost Discharge deals 3 damage to any target. All gho...

Votes: Rithaniel, Krishnath Love all the cards themed around science today. As a science teacher, I approve! In addition to voting for Rithaniel, HMs for RattingRots and shukkets. Thrummingbird Wings 1U Enchantment — Aura (U) Enchant creature When Thrummingbird Wings enters the battlefield, put a +1...

It wasn't my intention to make you change your scores or your judgment in any way. That's still your own call to do. I just felt like pointing out something that I thought might have been overlooked. Glad to help.

I feel like playing with fire intervening in this, but I do want to mention one thing while trying to stay as neutral as possible, as it's not my own bracket nor I am the host this month. It's true that Scarred Alpha doesn't give out +1/+1 counters as a direct effect itself but it only grants an abi...

Votes: Rithaniel, emily Boros Instructor 3RR Creature — Minotaur Warrior (U) Mentor (Whenever this creature attacks, put a +1/+1 counter on target attacking creature with lesser power.) Boros Instructor has trample as long as you control a creature with a +1/+1 counter on it. "Here, let me show...

Round 1 was soil (black list), round 2 added mist (blue list). So I need to make a black card about mist and a blue card about soil that mirror each other. Liquefying Soil XUU Instant(R) Up to X target creatures each get -X/-0 until end of turn. "This is what happens when underground water infi...

Done. Conclave Harmonizer 1GW Creature - Elf Shaman (MR) 2G : Until end of turn, whenever you cast a green spell, create a 1/1 green Saproling token. 2W : Until end of turn, whenever you cast a white spell, put a +1/+1 counter on a creature you control. 3GW : Until end of turn whenever you cast a mu...

Only thing that could have made them better would be if they also gave a bonus to plants, treefolk, and fungus, but it's not that important. I honestly just didn't think about that, and the card is already crowded enough as is. But this is a really nice idea that would fit perfectly as a second ver...

Votes: void_nothing RattingRots (though formatting is wrong and I partly share slimytrout's concerns, but I just love the design) emily Really weird indeed. Neither of them are hyphenated in the Italian translation, that's why I had never seen the title spelled with a hyphen before. This a new thing...

Votes: Sagharri, emily Is Moby-Dick really hyphenated in English? In the Italian translation it's not, but I admit I don't know the original. By the way, the attribution should be on its own line with no spaces right after the dash. slimytrout - The card should specify what happens if there's a tie ...

Going to extend the critique period for the first two rounds by 24 hours - you have until 23:59 Eastern tomorrow, so get your critiques and top 3s in! I misread the critique deadline, I thought it was the 18th, not the 16th. I've just realized my mistake now, so this is much appreciated. Sounds fun...

Going to extend the critique period for the first two rounds by 24 hours - you have until 23:59 Eastern tomorrow, so get your critiques and top 3s in! I misread the critique deadline, I thought it was the 18th, not the 16th. I've just realized my mistake now, so this is much appreciated. Themes: Sp...