Of these, only Anguished Unmaking exiles. The rest are all destroy effects. Resculpt and Return to Dust are in the top 20, and Utter End is in the top 30. Either way, the vast majority of removal spells that are in decks don't hit indestructible artifacts - most people aren't willing to pay a premi...

Indestructible artifacts are also pretty tricky to deal with - while creature exile is pretty common, it is less common for people to go out of their way to exile artifacts and enchantments. This means you are likely to have the opportunity to protect your commander a second time if it is removed. ...

Oh man when 3drinks sees that Hail Caesar deck he's gonna fall in love all over again. 🥰😂

Meanwhile me: oh great, get ready for more 12min Salvaging Station turns. 🙄😐💀

Recurring Nightmare and G-Brand unban when? Don't give me that crap that G-Brand is busted when we can play a legal tutour that gets the exact card we want at a given time for 2 life and a sacrifice. 0 mana universal tutour > 0 mana random seven off the top. Full stop. You can't fool me, you only w...

Ohh, marath is something I haven't seen in quite a few years. Like a hardened scales deck yeah? Bet we can build it like modern scales so I'll vote that!

I like MH1 snows! Anything to show that Dead of Winter is just as good as Toxic Deluge! 🙃

Thanks for introducing this place to me, 3drinks!! Maybe some time I'll come out of my shell more and not just play in that community build game. 🤔

Idk. You have to spend two on your own turn to get the card you want. I'd much rather see you cast this than any of the MIR tutors. Demonic tutor is just undercosted, not bannable I think. It, diabolic intent, and grim tutor are important to ensure you can find the answer you need but without being ...

I'd yay the screwdriver, sure! I will wait and see the discourse on thought-knot seer.

I support Endbringer, Matter Reshaper, and The One Ring!

Well if we're adding in a bunch of two cost rocks, I'm going to go higher. Let's run Khalni Gem which effectively costs two after rebate.

I always love me a good sculpting steel, even if it is kinda dated? Is Mirage Mirror better typically? Well I'm gonna yay it regardless but I think there's room for conversation, easy! I don't understand why we keep saying hangarback works with deathmantle? Hangarback's trigger cares about the count...

My initial inclination is, "is skittering cicada too much of this effect?" But then it's superior to shimmer myr in every way, right? So I think this is a yay, but we should also ask the question if it replaces shimmer myr or if we want three of this effect? I like Reality Smasher but I do...

What do people say about winter orb? Isn't that gonna turn people off maybe?

Hmm, idk, these days I have more fun on the Switch, but I guess if counting these forums then maybe 1-3 hours a week? Idk it's been easy to not get super into the weeds since most new cards are just side grades really.

I would yay Diving Top and Liberator, yeah! And I'll raise you a Shimmer Myr. Most our stuff is artifacts and this'll almost be a second Liberator, right?

Edhrec is constantly talking about this card and I think the juice is totally worth her squeeze! No sacrifice needed.

darrenhabib wrote: ↑

6 months ago

@3drinks

I'd vote for the good inspector! We're probably gonna play a lot of artifacts anyway, I'm sure it's got hits.

I'd like to change my nay to a yay on Deathmantle. And a yay for what's probably the best trinket mage target of all time, retrofitter foundry.

I like Deathmantle if we're on Su-Chi / Cathodion (I think su-chi is out of budget right?) otherwise what else are we using it for? Giving colorless creatures intimidate and then adding a color is worse than, say, just giving them an Executioner's Hood . So I think this has to be a nay as presented ...

I think 3drinks is going though a struggle over finding pirates for under $40 shipped. He doesn't want to buy it but he's clearly interested and I'm gonna keep poking at him when he shows up with them 🤣. Definitely caught him rebrewing in his head a time or two at work 👀🙈 Really though, of something...

Think it's pretty clear that we can break parity on the best stax piece in the format, so that's a yay from me!

Ooh, Ugin. I for one will yay our dragon overlord. Palladium Myr too. I am not sold on Oblivion Sower. How often does it actually hit? These cards that look at the top X cards in a 99 card deck always feel like a whiff to me, idk maybe I'm wrong. I think that's a nay for that reason.

Ohhhh, wait I was up? Well how about Calamity of the Titans? We can't have just All is Dust after all.