The Legacy forum is still getting up and running. Would you mind sharing your list? I haven't seen a list using Hall before. What are you recurring with it?

Commander 2019 hits soon. Anything you think will make a splash? Two cards stand out to me: Mire in Misery - Two mana edicts are routinely good in Grixis builds. Liliana's Triumph and Angrath's Rampage are currently seeing play. Mire gives the option to hit enchantments as well, which has a few appl...

Historic isn't even actually a format yet, since we haven't hit rotation and won't for another 2 months. I could definitely see it coming to paper, however. As far as concerns of the format being broken too quickly, do note that the current standard is exceptionally diverse and fairly well balanced,...

spacemonaut, There's a thread in the main section of the Legacy format that describes the precise breakdown used to split between Proven, Established, and Developing. We're using MTGtop8 metagame share numbers to make the actual call as to where something falls between Proven and Established, but th...

I've been playing BR/BU Reanimator for a bit, and Faithless Looting just...feels bad. It can't be a T1 play in addition to a Reanimate spell unless you cast it off of a Petal, and more often than not, you want to be doing something other than drawing and discarding T1. The problem is the same with ...

Will there be a dedicated trading/sales board? There are no plans for this at this time. Trades on MTGSalvation drastically dwindled in the past several years, despite having significant infrastructure built with the Trading Post, trade feedback, and the Bad Trade Report Adjudication system. While ...

Mono-Red prison is a powerful deck, but it has a few vulnerabilities: 1) Its prison pieces are all fairly targeted. If you're running a deck like Miracles or Grixis Control that runs a fair number of basics to beat Blood Moon, can get to three lands with regularity to beat Trinisphere, and isn't all...

This seems like a good way to support the format, but it has people up in arms about printing more mechanically unique, standard-legal cards that aren't available in booster packs. The collector boosters help bridge this gap to some extent, but they will be very expensive and have a low print-run, ...

Ashnod and Tawnos are two big ones. There's a whole pile of old Planeswalkers that never got cards: Leshrac, Tevesh Szat, Taysir, Bo Levar, Commodore Guff, etc. There's a number of old characters who have gotten woefully inadequate cards as well: Gerard is primary among them, but there's also Volrath.

New site, new "Crazy Plays in Commander" thread. Post your notable games here! I'll get us started off. Let me set the stage here. I'm playing Teysa Karlov , to my left is my buddy playing a Silas Renn, Seeker Adept / Sidar Kondo of Jamuraa Morph/Saboteur deck, to his left is Kami of the C...

I added those, plus
Multiplayer
Commander
Various sizes (i.e. 360 450 540 etc)
Draft-Sim

If you think of any more, make another post and tag me in it.

First and foremost, before posting here or anywhere else, be sure to read the MTG Nexus Forum Rules. All rules outlined there are also enforced here. Cube lists, Card discussion, and Archetype Discussion belong in their respective sections. Pauper and Peasant Cubes have their own sections. If you ac...

All MTGNexus sitewide rules apply. Banlist discussion should be reserved for the Legacy Banlist Discussion Thread . Decklists should be posted in the Developing section. If you would like to create or take over a Primer for an Established or Proven deck, please message one of the Legacy Moderators, ...

Personally, I think they use an overly draconian cutoff over at The Source.

The Humor community is designed to be a catch-all for humorous Magic-related content. As a fun-focused, rules regarding spam are greatly relaxed, and solicitation of outside articles, videos, and other humorous things is allowed, as long as it it not done in an overly spammy fashion. There are a few...

In-depth Explanation of Individual Rules The list below is not intended to be all-inclusive of the offenses that may cause warnings or infractions; the MTGNexus staff reserves the right to issue warnings and infractions for offenses not listed. If you are at any point unsure about the rules, wonder...

MTGNexus Official Community Rules and Guidelines Welcome to MTGNexus, a community-based Magic: The Gathering site aimed at creating a welcoming community for Magic players to discuss their game, as well as providing tools to facilitate these discussions. Before posting, please take some time to fam...

Core 2020 will be the set that introduces the London Mulligan as an official rule. Breakdown based, in large part, on Core 2019 and will be adjusted as needed. Projected Breakdown: 1/16 Mythic Rares 1/53 Rares 1/80 Uncommons 0/111 Commons 15/15 Basic Lands 18/280 Total Guide: Bold with link [/u][/co...

Please post any and all Core 2020 Rulings Questions here!

The Previews section is exclusively for posting official, Wizards of the Coast-sponsored Previews, as well as Wizards announcements of upcoming products as well as other significant, Magic -related news such as rules changes, ban announcements, and announcements of related media like tie-in board ga...

Here's the general outline of what I'd like to see from a Legacy primer: 1) Decklist(s). This should include the primer-writer's preferred decklist as well as a couple of decklists from major events. Ideally these should cover any significant sub-archetype variants. E.g. for Eldrazi Stompy, there sh...

I'm leaning towards 2% being in the Proven group because all of those decks are reasonably significant in the meta.

Proposal: Three primary decklist forums. 1) Proven/The Meta: Decks that have a significant meta share. I would define this as >2% (or maybe >=2%) of the meta on MTGTop8 for the current year (in April or after) or the previous year (Jan-March). These are the "decks to beat" in the Legacy me...