Punish Mint
Creature — Plant Horror (Uncommon)
Punish Mint gets +1/+0 for each other creature named Punish Mint you control.
Whenever an opponent discards a card, create a token that's a copy of Punish Mint.
1/1

Dunes of Forgotten Dreams Legendary Land — Desert (Mythic) Dunes of Forgotten Dreams enters the battlefield tapped. When Dunes of Forgotten Dreams enters the battlefield, mill four cards. [sym=t]: Add [sym=c]. [sym=t]: Exile four target cards from your graveyard. If you can't, sacrifice Dunes of Fo...

Thallid Thicket
Land — Forest (Uncommon)
(: Add .)
At the beginning of your upkeep, put a spore counter on Thallid Thicket.
Remove three spore counters from Thallid Thicket: Create a 1/1 green Saproling creature token.

Just a top three. I might come back and do critiques, but, knowing me, probably not.

Top 3:
3rd: KB52665
2nd: kwanyeegor-ii
1st: Komandon

Adhesive Ooze [sym=1][sym=b][sym=g] Creature — Ooze (Rare) When Adhesive Ooze enters the battlefield, you may have it become an Aura enchantment with enchant creature. If you do, attach it to target creature. Enchanted creature can't attack or block, and its activated abilities can't be activated. ...

Top 3:
3rd: KB52665
2rd: kwanyeegor-ii
1st: Komandon

Mount Tanufel Legendary Land — Mountain (R) Mount Tanufel enters the battlefield tapped. [sym=t]: Add [sym=w]. [sym=2][sym=wb][sym=br], [sym=t]: At the beginning of your next upkeep, it becomes night. Daybound (If a player casts no spells during their own turn, it becomes night next turn.) // Mount...

Cold-Blooded Killer [sym=1][sym=r] Creature — Lizard Assassin Cold-Blooded Killer enters the battlefield with a haste counter on it. Whenever Cold-Blooded Killer deals combat damage to an opponent, you may remove a haste counter from it. If you do, it deals damage equal to its power to target creat...

Top 3:
3rd: marioguy3
2nd: Henlock
1st: void_nothing

KB52665 — I don't know. I mean, in my opinion, this should enter tapped. I'd say its a bit too strong as is. Komandon — I don't understand what part of this is "singing", so I will just assume you meant singeing. Though, why is this even a desert (aside from the fact you need it to be for...

Sandstorm Whirler [sym=3][sym=g][sym=g] Creature — Elemental (R) Flying When Sandstorm Whirler enters the battlefield, put a creature card from your graveyard onto the battlefield face down and tapped. It's a Desert land with "[sym=t]: Add [sym=c]" and "[sym=5]: Turn this permanent f...

Lorn Asbord Schutta — I mean, it's certainly interesting. I don't really know what else to say about this card, other than that I don't understand the use of Samildánach as its name. Raptorchan — This name doesn't quite scream legendary to me. I'd think this itself would have flying, but. Also, tha...

What is fiction and what is reality is a question often asked in Illukar a plane were illusions are so prominent that people can't tell the difference between illusion and reality and as a result of the planes boosting of illusions the illusions here are as good as reality and two people can see thi...

There's a bit of rhyme going on with that flavor text I've notices, but I'm fairly certain the word you want is "foils", not "fails". No, I do mean fails. In fact, I fail to see how foils would work there at all. Even those sworn to keep the living from the dead have a price. On...

Ferryman of Final Rests [sym=4][sym=w][sym=w] Creature — Spirit (C) Flying, vigilance Tribute 3 (As this creature enters the battlefield, an opponent of your choice may put three +1/+1 counters on it.) When Ferryman of Final Rests enters the battlefield, if tribute wasn't paid, exile target player'...

Dessert Desert
Artifact Land — Food Desert (C)
Indestructible
Dessert Desert enters the battlefield tapped.
: Add .
, , Sacrifice Dessert Desert: You gain 3 life and draw a card.

The Flying Dutchman [sym=1][sym=w][sym=u] Legendary Artifact — Vehicle (M) Flying Whenever The Flying Dutchman attacks a player who controls Old Letters, create two 1/1 white and blue Spirit creature tokens with flying that are tapped and attacking. Crew 2 Forecast — Tap two untapped white and/or b...

Henlock — I feel like this is just better than Extraction Specialist . Also, that "it is" on your card should be the contraction "it's". Also, you have a double comma. OneAndOnly — A bit confusing on first read. Not like I'm one to talk though. Interesting concept. Let's see, te...

Internal Organ-ized [sym=2][sym=b][sym=b][sym=b] Sorcery (Un-Mythic) Return all Zombie creature cards from your graveyard to the battlefield in a stack. Order the stack alphabetically with "A" at the top. Whenever that stack would leave the battlefield, exile the top card of it instead. T...

@void_nothing, exiling a (permanent) card from a graveyard, then returning that to the battlefield doesn't count, right? Also, does cloaking/manifesting a card in a graveyard count?

Agonistic Elite
Creature — Human Soldier
Haste
Agonistic Elite attacks each combat if able.
When Agonistic Elite enters, suspect it.
Pay 1 life: Tap or untap Agonistic Elite.
3/1

@Komandon, same thing applies to you. You cannot have me in your top 3 because I was not one of the six above you. (Your list was meant to be: marioguy3, netn10, shullz, Raptorchan, OneAndOnly, and Henlock.)

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3? No, absolutely not. The brackets are there to determine who can score points from whom and give everyone a shot. Thank you. That's what I thought, but it's good to have confirmation before I call out another user. ma...

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3?

[sym=unknown]|Attribute||Inherits|Card Name -:|:-|-:|:-|:- [sym=wubrg]|Color |[sym=B] | Black | Herald of the Dreadhorde [sym=x]|MV |[sym=3] | Three | Robber Fly [sym=multitype]|Type |[sym=Enchantment]|Enchantment| Firebreathing [sym=t]|Abilities | | | Tobias Andrion [hr] Lasting Nothingness 1BB En...