Judgeholder. I will certainly be making use of the time I have to make sure I'm happy with these, so I won't declare them done yet, but I will accept questions/concerns. [hr] Design (1.5/3) Appeal - Not a whole lot of Timmy appeal (deathtouch is fine, turning their own creatures into a 1/1 less so),...

Eh, sign me up. Seems like it'll be another interesting month to judge for. Also means both void and Leo can compete in one of these for once.

And my April MCC Round 4 judgments are complete. There is still time to ask questions, of course.

I will say, this was a very interesting month to judge, and fun too.

Quality - 11 lines of text with 4 breaks is well beyond microtext, where the limit with 4 breaks is 9 lines, or 1 break for 11 lines. Should be "if it has" not "if it is with" Huh. I have checked my submission before posting with local Nexus card creator and I had exactly nine l...

Done. [hr] Design (2.5/3) Appeal - That's a lot of keywords, but the 1 power leaves Timmy a bit underwhelmed. Johnny kind of likes what it offers, especially since the tutor from outside the game is curiously functional outside of the draft. This is mostly a Spike card, though like Timmy they would ...

I have to say, I expected "Design a legendary noncreature with "can be your commander" in its rules text." for the main challange in the finals. The whole month kept surprising me, honestly, which is good. Being kept on your toes is part of what makes a challange itself in the f...

Ooo, they're finally doing 'multicolor' with C. They still refuse to unmoor C from the Eldrazi, but it's interesting, at least.

That does look like a reasonable set up. Would certainly require honor on the part of the Keeper, but I expect of anyone you certainly would be trustworthy.

I am curious why the policy knowledge you mentioned might be relevant, after taking a look at what they are.

My March MCC Round 3 judgments are done.

Definitely an interesting challenge with interesting considerations.

Judgments rendered [hr] Design (3/3) Appeal - I'd say this is an all-rounder; can get big, has combo interest, and is efficient. (2.5/3) Elegance - A fair amount of tracking involved if a player intends to keep delirium active while using this ability, plus tracking the amount of die rolls, but othe...

@Ink-Treader: by the way, main challenge was "Design a permanent card", so not all cards in your bracket pass this challenge, even. And to make it more fair, personally I forgot to make my card legendary... Fortunately doesn't alter who advances, but I do seem to be slipping up a bit this...

My April MCC Round 2 judgments are complete.

Vote: shullz, Lorn Asbord Schutta

Alright, I think this will be fine. The scores being in the same order as the critiques is an interesting coincidence. [hr] Design (2/3) Appeal - Timmy will find this kind of neat. This might have some Johnny appeal, in the form of being able to use two decks to assemble one combo, and the fact that...

Vote: Hexbolt0505, OneAndOnly

Vote: AntGamerGOD, Lorn Asbord Schutta

Vote: netn10, void_nothing Drizzling Ectoplasm 4{W/U}{W/U} Sorcery (R) Spirit offering (You may cast this spell any time you could cast an instant by sacrificing a Spirit and paying the difference in mana costs between this and the sacrificed Spirit. Mana cost includes color.) Each creature your opp...

Vote: Lorn Asbord Schutta, JovialJovian Eulogy for Creation 3{G/W}{G/W} Enchantment (R) Whenever one or more creature, planeswalker and/or battle cards are exiled from a graveyard, create a 2/2 green Wolf Whenever one or more land, artifact and/or enchantment cards are exiled from a graveyard, you g...

Vote: Lorn Asbord Schutta, void_nothing

Charlatan's Coin 2
Artifact - Treasure (U)
T: The next time you would flip a coin, choose the result of that flip instead.
T, Sacrifice Charlatan's Coin: Add one mana of any color.

IIW: A world where time is winding down.

Vote: OneAndOnly, void_nothing Saint Cherlia, Evercaring 1GW Legendary Creature - Elf Cleric (R) Lifelink When Saint Cherlia enters the battlefield and at the beginning of your upkeep, put a hexproof counter and an indestructible counter on another target creature you control with base power and/or ...

Vote: Lorn Asbord Schutta, void_nothing

There's a bit of rhyme going on with that flavor text I've notices, but I'm fairly certain the word you want is "foils", not "fails". No, I do mean fails. In fact, I fail to see how foils would work there at all. Even those sworn to keep the living from the dead have a price. On...

I have finished my April MCC Round 1 judgments.

All done. It seems 5 will be advancing from my pool. EDIT: It was pointed to me that a part of one my critiques was left blank. This had no impact on the score; I know exactly why it ended up blank. EDIT 2: I have had to make an impactful score change, reducing the number of advancing players to 5. ...

Vote: klutzedufus, void_nothing Sosvu'nal, the Whispers 5U{U/B}B Legendary Creature - Horror (M) Sosvu'nal has protection from players with three or fewer cards in hand. Forecast - 2UB , Reveal Sosvu'nal, the Whispers from your hand: Each player discards two cards, then each player draws a card. Whi...