Enigmatic Mirage 1UU Creature — Illusion (U) Whenever Enigmatic Mirage becomes the target of a spell or ability an opponent controls, sacrifice Enigmatic Mirage, then draw a card. 1UU : Choose one — • Enigmatic Mirage gains hexproof until end of turn. • Change a target of target spell or ability an...

Votes: Sagharri, Flatline FoilSquared (The word "flying" should not be capitalized and a period is missing at the end of the sentence. Yes, I pay attention to such details...) netn10 (I really like the card, I just liked the two I voted for even more.) I have said in my judgment of Flatlin...

I'll add myself to the congratulations to Rithaniel as well! My judgments for October Round 1 have been posted. I have a tie for fourth place, so five players from my bracket advance. And one of the tied players is you, [mention]Flatline[/mention]. You didn't get a zero in Quality, after all there w...

A few comments about the final poll for September. It amazed me (and made my choice very difficult) the fact that both submissions were more or less the same to me: one card that's in the wrong colors, one or two cards that didn't really excite me, and only one or two cards that made me go like &quo...

Votes: RattingRots, Rithaniel Designing cards based on scientific concepts is a very good way to catch my attention, even if I'm not the biggest fan of the mechanics. I would like this card more if it only cared about you instead of "each player", obviously adjusting the costs. I feel like...

No worries [mention]Flatline[/mention], I'll take your entry as you posted before me officially closing the round, which, by the way, is exactly what I'm doing right now with this post. Round is officially closed. Brackets follow. BRACKETS Judge: bravelion83 barbecube Flatline Freyleyes Henlock Kris...

I'm closing the judge signups for now. What we need now are more players, not more judges. I'll reopen them if needed, but I honestly don't think that it will be the case, at least for now.
If you're interested in playing, please check out the Round 1 thread.

Votes: Krishnath, netn10 Time to Act XR Sorcery (U) Goad up to X target creatures. (Until your next turn, those creatures attack each combat if able and attack a player other than you if able.) "There are some moments when you just can't stop to think and ponder your next action. You just have ...

My judgments for the final round of September have been posted. A reminder that the design deadline for October Round 1 is tomorrow night for now . Seeing the not very high participation, I might leave the round open if we don't have at the very least two more entries (15 total) by this time tomorr...

Votes: Krishnath, netn10 Flatline, Sagharri Transformist Dragon 3UR Creature — Dragon Shapeshifter (R) Flying At the beginning of each upkeep, you may pay 2 . If you do, scry 2, then reveal the top card of your library. If that card is a creature card, until end of turn, Transformist Dragon's base p...

Judgments complete. All typos should have been fixed. Final Cleave 2BBBB Sorcery (R) Target player loses half their life, rounded down. Distribute X -1/-1 counter amongs any number of target creatures that player controls, where X is equal to the life lost by that player this turn. Design Appeal 3/...

Votes: slimytrout, Sagharri Honorable mentions for RattingRots. Hard Memory BGU Sorcery(U) Target player puts the top four cards of their library into their graveyard, then they choose a creature card and a noncreature card in their graveyard. That player returns the chosen cards to their hand. To m...

Votes: Krishnath, slimytrout RattingRots and Flatline - same reason, perfectly fine cards but I'm not a big fan of stealing your opponents' stuff. Sagharri - I think it needs to be Izzet. Maybe have it cost UR and bring the damage up to 3? Henlock - I laughed as I read the card. Very good humor. Man...

Can i get an example of how you expect Adventure cards templated please. It has been there since I first posted the round. Go to Clarifications spoiler > Main Challenge option-specific clarifications > Adventure. For everybody's convenience, here is the relevant part: • Q: How should I format my ad...

Votes: Flatline (welcome back!), netn10 Sagharri, Blydden Congratulations for the victory! I'll gladly take the second place, it's still my best result ever except for a tied victory years ago. Next step: win again, this time by myself! I was close this month... but I'm sure the right time for that ...

Ok, I'm willingly choosing to take a risk and try to play out of the box this round. I need to learn to do it more. What's the risk I'm taking here? Green vampires! It's the only color that doesn't have them: UB on Ravnica, BR on Innistrad, WB on Ixalan. Ruthless Lymphsucker BG Creature — Vampire (...

For Syr Lionheart, the Brave! ... Reply to [mention]Blydden[/mention]. In spoiler because it's long. In short, you're absolutely officially in! But there is a whole backstory that I want you in particular, and anybody else that might be interested in general, to know. So, here we go... So many &quo...

Votes: RattingRots, netn10 Many thanks for your wishes. It was definitely good enough, which, trust me, is a lot to say. Things like this make me feel like I'm at home on this site. At least there are people who care, which is also a lot to say. Again, thank you. This just can't be a coincidence. I'...

Fixed the two things! Ok, now it's good. Those two plus the lack of a shuffle clause were all the intended Quality mistakes, and I like your addendum to Balance. I'm glad to officially welcome you as an MCC judge. Should you need any help, advice, or anything, you know where to find me (probably be...

Being new doesn't prevent you from trying, as you've said yourself. Several years ago by now, on MTGSalvation, I went from lurker to player than judge and finally host all in the span of four months! The first four months I was active not just on MTGSalvation's CCCG subforum, but in any custom card ...

MCC-1910.png (This month's banner is my own elaboration on the art of the card Into the Story by Jason Rainville.) October MCC Round 1 Choose your own adventure Welcome to Eldraine, planeswalker! This is a world of royal courts and wild lands, brave knights and scary beasts, wretches and kings, dan...

Votes: Rithaniel, void_nothing I'm willingly choosing to ignore the name changing in the rules text as you've acknowledged the mistake yourself and I also just love the flavor of the card. Also, thank you very much for your wishes! Sagharri - I personally would expand Dryad Arbor into a real cycle r...

MCC-1910.png (This month's banner is my own elaboration on the art of the card Into the Story by Jason Rainville.) October MCC Judge signup thread The October MCC and our own story on the plane of Eldraine begin now! Who knows what adventures this beautiful place has in store for us this month? Wel...

I've just finished rereading my judgments for typos and fixing them. Going to prepare it right now and I'll post it as soon as I have it done. It shouldn't take more than a few minutes from this post. EDIT: it's up . The October MCC and our own story on the plane of Eldraine begin now! Who knows wha...

My own judgments (and prerelease stories, if you care about those) have been posted too here in the round thread.

Should I go ahead and post the judge signup thread for October already?