I would do Minn or Treebeard.

Rancor Yay
And I'll confirm Reanimate. I don't know if it is optimal, but I love stealing opponents' toys.

okay, I'm sold

Yay Bloodchief Ascension and Yay Ewit

3 drops do sound important. So does raw card draw.

I haven't weighed in on ascension because I didn't really get why we had it. It's good at closing the game, for sure. I don't agree with Cheonice about it making us a target - we are already a target since we are hitting fast, hard, and making everyone discard. BA will not change that. I just think ...

Nominating Sheoldred's Edict
I think Edicts will be very good in our deck. It makes combat harder for our opponents, and we can neglect tokens if we choose to.

My monoblue Kefnet deck has a mix of foil Rebecca Guay islands and foil islands from Theros (original set). My monoblack deck has all Theros Beyond Death full art swamps (the nyx ones). I think I was short a couple and put the Seb McKinnon Secret Lair swamps (full art, non foil). I would have liked ...

Block structure had to go. There was always a bad set. People always got bored and barely wanted to draft. That's why they started making third sets that were drafted alone, and the awesome Khans block where things really changed around. They were trying to find a solution. I thought the idea to cha...

Varragoth seems fine. Yay

Seasons Past seems really good but I worry it is not good in our fast out of the gate type of deck. I think it takes some runs with this deck to see if it will be good.
Not usually played on turn 6, and I don't think we want the game going much later than that.

I think Shizo is good enough for any deck with 2 or less colors to be honest. It's a good card.

I have one in Maelstrom Wanderer
Brainstorm and bounce are both really good with MW. I feel like I actually win most games where Jace comes down.

I would say that talking about the amount of self-discard should have been discussed because some of us didn't think about it and just looked at reclamation at face value. I would yay it now.


My nomination is Dark Ritual.

Yay intervention Nay reclamation - I don't think we quite have enough going to our graveyard for this to be better than literal Raise Dead in most games. Nay Undying Evil and friends. Mainly, no hexproof means they still can exile our permanents, which I believe is becoming more and more common. I a...

I've thought of nominating thoughtseize a few times but I do not think I would play it in this deck. It is really close.

I wanna hear from the rest before I vote.

Yay lethemancer I am going to say that 9 mana finishers aren't great for this deck, especially since this doesn't finish our opponents. Our commander brings down life totals quickly, so we need burn, not more halving of life totals. But mostly we are low to the ground and I don't think this deck has...

Yay Gary

I think for card draw I have settled on it being instant speed or 1-3 MV. Preferably 1-2 mana. I just don't really want to spend my turn 4 drawing 3 cards at sorcery. I also think in this deck we run the risk of our opponents being hellbent a lot of the time and this card only drawing 1-2 cards. So,...

I never understood what I was looking at. It looks like it was sewn into something leather. Or something pinned onto a cloth.

yay necrogen mists
I say we wait until the end of the build to see how many discard effects we have and see if we include Tinybones or Waste Not or Grimoire. But not all 3.

Any delayed flicker effects to pair with it?
Maybe okay with some play extra lands cards so you don't end up with a million cards in hand and no way to take advantage.

Nay on Grimoire. If we can't support Waste Not I don't see Grimoire being better. It's also a card that wants wheels more than single instances of discard. I am definitely open to reviewing Grimoire and Waste not at the end of this.

Bottomless Pit is my nomination.

I will yay Words of Waste I am concerned about Mindslicer. We don't have sac outlets (other than Rankle which Yay by the way). I don't like how dependant we are on opponents to trigger mindslicer and that they can use it to their advantage and our disadvantage (like killing it in our draw step). Wil...

I think exiling removal should be played more anyway, but the fact is that only White has good answers to it. Red has one? answer to this Green has some bad answers to this Blue has Ravenform and bounce (bounce is not great though) Black has nothing. There are some cards like Shadowspear which can h...

I love the design of windgrace's judgment, but was always concerned with the MV. The EV is strong, like Casualties of War , but if you need to kill something in a pinch it takes up your whole turn. I feel like this could be the right deck for it though. Essentially, we are coming hot out the gate, a...

Goose is right but Waste Not is so much fun I will not change my vote. Waste Not likes wheels especially (and Dark Deal is not worth playing I think).

My nomination is Liliana of the Veil. I like edicts for our deck, and I like her making everyone discard.

I will yay Waste Not, Oppression and Torment. I like that we found a subtheme that isn't recursion since we seem to do that a lot.