yay Aurelia

*Reminder to people to actually comment on all the cards up for nomination.*

Hermes_ wrote: ↑

7 months ago

is the price tag due to being in Legends or is there more to it?

Memes

I will nominate Fable of the Mirror-Breaker // Reflection of Kiki-Jiki
I think it does a lot for this deck. Helps us ramp a bit, helps us filter, doubling the attack trigger ain't bad and the copying ability should be great in this deck.

You'd find yourself passing into the Shadow World. You'd soon become a wraith, like cEDH players. Okay this made me laugh a lot. If it were me I'd eschew all the combos, but I recognize that my ethos puts me in the minority these days. As I say, if you're already running other combos then a single ...

I have been enamoured with Ratadrabik of Urborg since it was spoiled. I played it on Arena Brawl and something about making 5 Thalia, Guardian of Thraben s is super satisfying. I had been collecting some cards towards a deck for a while, and started sleeving it up. A few recent cards from Lord of th...

Yay Etali
I hate 4 mana to draw our first card. I would rather see night's whisper or impulsive draw. Nay bankbuster.

I am less interested in cards that can have any number of copies and more interested in cards like Nazgûl and Seven Dwarves that allow you to play a few more copies in Commander.

yay delina and hellrider
there was a Khans card that would double up on hellrider right?

Yay for drawbridge and sneak attack I will nominate Inferno Titan . I love the ability to snipe blockers and allow our attackers to get through. With haste it also delivers at least 12 damage. Adeline, Resplendent Cathar is good. Solid choice. Yay. The other haste enabler that could be interesting i...

Do we have a place to post low-effort stupid memes about magic? Is this the spot? Can I make a thread so no one has to have their eyes scalded by the dumb memes if they don't want to? I love dumb memes. Really annoys me that the mtg subreddit doesn't allow them. And freemagic is a real hive of scum...

Why doesn't Wall-E get any comments?
I love that movie. Maybe not S-tier but definitely better than some of your A-tiers.

Yay Myriel
Nay Emblem

I am in favour of some haste lands but we are 3 colors. They have to be good.

I think we need several haste enablers. Some will be creatures, some equipment, some enchantment and some lands. Maybe even a planeswalker.
Attack triggers are fun but without haste everyone has a chance to deal with them.

Rising of the day is easier to splash than Hammer.

My nomination is Rising of the Day

Bad finisher in multiplayer

Okay so Sun Titan is like 30x better than Bishop of Rebirth. It attacks better, has an ETB, can snag lands and other permanents. That being said, I think there are better curve toppers for this deck. Etali, Inferno Titan, Scourge of the Throne and Aurelia can be gamewinning with haste. Sun Titan sna...

Yay Sword of the Animist, Goldspan and Captain Lannery.

I was at a sales meeting, but if not too late I would nominate Lightning Greaves

I think it is easy for this type of deck to get too high CMC. Etali, Titans, Drakuseth, etc. I think the power of the deck will be to flood the board early, drop the commander and smack face.
So 6 and 7 drops are not great and should be limited.

I think haste enablers, extra combat steps, and big attack triggers is how I would go, but I think this is a timmy way of building it.
Probably a low cmc swarm with Hellrider effects would be better?

Like if I made this I would put Drakuseth, Maw of Flames and ignore good removal spells.

Very sad. He was young. A great loss to his family, and certainly to magic.

I put 6-8 hours, but this is spread over the course of months most of the time. Sometimes years. I get an idea, and put a few cards that suit that idea into a box. Since I am short on time, I don't tend to look at my collection very often. Every once in a while I add a couple cards, or bookmark a co...

I vote Isshin, Two Heavens as One for extra Etali triggers.

2. Homeward path type cards exist. Usually worth waiting a minute and seeing if someone can find one. If by " Homeward Path type cards" you mean literally just Homeward Path , then yes, I suppose that's true... But, someone has to be playing it, they have to find it, and they need to deci...

I actually think Minn would have been more interesting without the ability to cheat things in.

Minn pushes us to broken things, and probably has some optimal cards that need to be included that will take up a lot of the deck. I do like that it is monocolored. It also feels like we are going to spam illusions to cheat in Omniscience or something. Treebeard pushes towards lifegain voltron. This...