emily, netn10

Shadow Replica 2RR
Enchantment - Aura (R)
Enchant Creature
Enchanted creature has double strike.
Whenever enchanted creature becomes the target of a spell, you may attach ~ to another target creature.

netn10, emily I love this card, but I'm ambivalent about making the main casting cost the same as the evoke cost. First of all I think clone with flash is probably pushing it, so personally making it 3UU or something might be better just from a balance perspective. As for making the costs equal, I t...

hm: almost voted for rattingrots, but I think it's substantially too strong to be common -- straight up 4-mana draw two at instant speed is already a reasonable common card, and I don't think an extra U in the casting cost balances out adding a counterspell mode. I think looking back, uncommon is p...

Thanks for the feedback, and I'm glad you liked the design. I woud have actually argued that, when this spell is played, things tend to equalize more than anything, though. Like, if a 9/9 is attacking into a 3/3, then the person with the 3/3 now has nine 1/1 flyers, where the person with the 9/9 ha...

Some comments over the past 2 days: Votes: bravelion83, shukkets Once Forgotten Goblin [sym=3][sym=r] Creature - Goblin (Uncommon) Of Memory (You may exile this card from your hand. Whenever you cast a goblin spell, if Once Forgotten Goblin is in exile, put a retrieval counter on Once Forgotten Gobl...

bravelion83, slimytrout HM: netn10 Horizon Pursuant 2W Creature - Human Explorer (U) When ~ enters the battlefield, look at the top four cards of your library. You may reveal a permanent card with converted mana cost 2 or less from among them and put it into your hand. Put the rest on the bottom of ...

Rithaniel, marioguy3 (only thing is GB seems a bit awkward - haven't seen enough spoilers to say if white is a good food color, but I would go with WB or WG I think) Lot of good submissions and I have some comments but I'm too tired to write them down currently. Think Again 2UU Instant (C) Choose on...

slimytrout, emily HM: netn10 (I realize this has some symmetry and costs multiple cards most of the time, but I do think it's still overpowered for a player that has a plan for how to use it) Soul Sucker 2B Creature - Vampire (U) Flying Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, you draw cards and ...

Happy to continue this in the discussion thread if you still disagree, but I think the "only any time you could activate a sorcery" rider makes this card much less busted. With that rider, it's very hard to engineer a situation where you get full value out of the creature *and* get to tak...

netn10, slimytrout HM: bravelion83 (but I would personally make this card a bit more expensive or restrictive because it has some abusable modes now) Mad Sandwalla 1R Creature - Lizard (C) Whenever you discard a card, ~ gets +1/+1 until end of turn. 1/2 EDIT: Changed votes after correctly reading ca...

I think the biggest thing is to only look at one library, and try to minimize the number of times you look. I'd guess counting cards in library takes about as much time/effort as shuffling, so doing it once or twice is totally fine. I think if one card is making you do it with both libraries potenti...

No love for Nlia? Too bad. I'll have to come up with a way to make her more interesting. I think Nlia would work a lot better in a purely digital card game than MtG - as it is you have to constantly keep track of the number of cards in multiple libraries. Determination of Nlia is better because at ...

Extremely good submissions today. slimytrout, netn10 almost everyone: bravelion83 (I think this works better as a keyword, and with a shorter period of time) Also Krishnath, Rithaniel, Sagharri, emily Gang Up XB Instant (U) Collective 1B (You may play this card for its collective cost. If you do, th...

bravelion83, netn10 Personally my view is that hate cards that are fringe playable in most cases, but are great against the thing they're hating are great, but cards that are actually good against everything are oppressive. I think this is a nice design and flavorful, but it would make the non-hate ...

Votes:
slimytrout (I've thought of a similar effect, would take a bit of clarification about simultaneous reveal or taking turns but IMO worth it)
netn10

Also don't forget to vote!

Scientific Method 2UU
Enchantment (U)
When ~ ETB, draw 2 cards
Discard 2 cards: Return ~ to it's owner's hand.

bravelion83, sagharri Cabal Interrogator 2BB Creature - Horror (R) Menace When ~ enters the battlefield, target opponent may reveal a non-land card from their hand. If they do, put two -1/-1 counters on ~. [sym=T], Sacrifice a creature: Name a non-land card. Target opponent reveals their hand and di...

Henlock, Sagharri

Reckless Ritual 1R
Sorcery (U)
Add RR.
The next creature that enters the battlefield under your control this turn gets +2/+0 and gains haste until end of turn.

slimytrout, Rithaniel

Pirate's Cove
Land (U)
: Add .
: Add one mana of any type an artifact you control could produce.

emily, Sagharri

HM: netn10 (modern allstar right there )

Master Wrangler 2W
Creature - Human Cowboy (U)
1W, : Untap target attacking creature and remove it from combat.
0/3

bravelion83, emily

Sylvan Pioneer 1G
Creature - Elf Druid (C)
When ~ enters the battlefield choose one:
-Put a land card from your hand onto the battlefield.
-Search your library for a basic land card, reveal it and put it into your hand.
1/1

marioguy3 - I like the card but it's just a functional reprint of Gelatinous Genesis , and "functional" only because the creature type of the tokens is different, otherwise it would just be a straight up reprint. I'm guessing he just didn't realize it was already a card. I forgot about Ge...

Bravelion83, Rithaniel (although I would consider making it rare)

HMs: Henlock, Sagharri

Exit Interview 1U
Sorcery (C)
As an additional cost to cast ~, return target creature you control to its owner's hand.
Draw two cards.

Sagharri, marioguy3 I really liked both of these, and essentially didn't vote for them because of minor templating/costing issues. Rithaniel - I'm not sure if I'm allowed to search for 2 different types (like a creature and an instant for example). I think I would be able to, but the wording is a li...

emily, void_nothing Bravelion - love this, but I think I'd give it flash so it can be used as a combat trick. Tidal Prison U Enchantment - Aura (U) Enchant Creature Retract 2 (This permanent enters the battlefield with 2 time counters on it. At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter fro...

Sagharri, Henlock

Detente WWBB
Enchantment (R)
Vanishing 3 (This permanent enters the battlefield with 3 time counters on it. At the beginning of your upkeep, remove a time counter from it. When the last is removed, sacrifice it.)
Players can't win or lose the game.