Sunday, March 29th, 2020; the Time Spiral Storage Lands calciform pools dreadship reef molten slagheap saltcrusted steppe fungal reaches Mage-Ring Network Easily the best of the storage land cycles cycle, but how often do you play these? In what decks is it appropriate to do so (beyond the obvious ...

I've been working on a Marisi, Breaker of the Coil Tribal Cats build with equipment subtheme. I have found it to be fun and interesting. Nacatl War-Pride is an interesting finisher on the back of Goad since (ideally) most of their creatures would be tapped from attacking and Breath of Fury does wond...

Riffle shuffle seven times . The Gilbert–Shannon–Reeds model provides a mathematical model of the random outcomes of riffling, that has been shown experimentally to be a good fit to human shuffling and that forms the basis for a recommendation that card decks be riffled seven times in order to rando...

Sinis wrote: ↑

4 years ago

but what you're asking for here is tantamount to an unmeetable burden of proof

I'm sorry. I was not trying to set any burden of proof (much less an impossible one).

I am genuinely curious of there is *any* data other than EDHRec implying a lack of casual use(s) of/for Flash.

I mostly play online, where WotC has made rule 0 obsolete in MTGO (chat used to open when the table was made, before the game was launched, now the game chat doesn't open until after the game has launched - too late to discuss anything or possibly switch decks) ******* In paper, in addition to simpl...

* There is no meaningful casual play of Flash * Everyone has wanted flash banned since hulk got unbanned I would like to see some data on this that isn't an "EDHRec" percentage number. For example here , in this thread, I posted about how I am currently running Flash . I have never posted...

I know Sheldon already answered some things here, in thread; but did the actual AMA ever post? https://articles.starcitygames.com/premium/menerys-mailbag-ask-me-anything/ Danke mucho. [Lots of Competitive Commander (CC?, Com 2 ?) back-and-forth] It seems easy to me, but maybe I'm a senile moron. I ...

I know Sheldon already answered some things here, in thread; but did the actual AMA ever post?

I discuss Tribal EDH here . Keeping in mind my personal preference of 1/3 "on-tribe" (using the Tribal Identity concept) I have made or currently have built the following: * denotes a type mismatch between the deck and the General (which I only tend to use when there is no suitable general...

Aside from the great non-creature support cards that may match your deck's TI (e.g. Luminarch Ascension in an Angel Deck), here are some tribal synergy cards you may want to consider: Stoneforge Masterwork Konda's Banner Heirloom Blade Herald's Horn Icon of Ancestry Urza's Incubator Door of Destinie...

cryogen wrote: ↑

5 years ago

MTGCommander.net - Official website for Commander, where you will find the most up to date rules and ban list, as well as their own forum.

Sadly, this probably needs to be updated...

For those playing on MTGO. Do you make any card or deck decision because you are playing on MTGO? Even though I so far only play with friends while on a discord channel, I still mostly play sorcery speed decks (maelstrom wanderer for example). Just because keeping mana up and responding is such a p...

I've been considering getting a laptop style device to make it easier to post things here, I enjoy the community and discussion and it is difficult to take part and keep up when I'm using a phone. ... If you play MTGO, how does playing EDH online compare to sitting down with humans? I've played MTG...

On a separate note, I implore the RC not to ban Flash . I'm really curious why you don't want Flash banned. Regarding Flash, cEDH players often cite the card's relative unpopularity as justification for its ban. We already know that a card's ubiquity can put it on the RC's radar for a potential ban...

Hope you are still doing well. 1) Status of the official forums? (Really missing them) 1a) Will content from the old forums be retrievable/archive-able? 1b) Will data-centric "posts" from the old forum be made into content on the new website (e.g. the Graveyard Hate and Unique Casting Cost...

" How do you go about conceiving of and building your craziest/coolest/most fun and unusual decks?". Well, I almost always build Tribal (as seen here ) and sometimes I try a deckbuilding challenge such as Rainbow Stairwell (as seen here ). When building tribal*, I try to look for synergie...

I have a Rainbow Stairwell Elemental Tribal Horde of Notions deck ( here ) which was a fun challenge to build and is interesting to pilot. I also enjoy my Sydri, Galvanic Genius Vehicle deck (U or Crew) that gets some weird looks. My Enduring Ideal deck ( Scion of the Ur-Dragon ) has an interesting ...

Nyxbloom Ancient really does seem like a win-more card; which does not mean I won't try it out in my RS Elemental Tribal since the current 7CMC Green slot is held by Zendikar Resurgent . Though, I expect the "double" mana and card draw will be more important than another beater with true-...

Really happy to see a new Chimera, especially one as nice as Treeshaker Chimera . I also hope that Hero of the Winds ' artwork means there will be new Griffins as well. Escape Velocity sounds like it should grant flying instead of haste based on the name... Only when considering a gravity well, spee...

As for how to fix it, I think that we are constantly working in that direction by trying to make this site less of a forum and more of a hub with things for users beyond just a message board. Whether we get the attention and ultimately the traffic remains to be seen. Considering the official site i...

Tuesday, December 17th, 2019; Teferi's Veil I used to play this back in the 90s with a Jokulhaups focused deck. Just swing with the team, and then scorch the earth. Terribly fun with Ball Lightning , too. True. I run this in my Horde of Notions Self-Sacrificing Elemental Tribal (all the Ball Lightn...

Morophon, the Boundless So are there other tribes people have used with Morophon? I build tribal almost exclusively (42 of 48 decks are tribal), and I have used/tried Morophon, the Boundless with: Werewolves/Wolves: This tribe got hosed in both Innistrad blocks. First, Huntmaster of the Fells wasn'...

Cards I have only seen in my own decks: Phyrexian Splicer - Many people seem to forget this is on the battlefield if it has been a few turns wince I used it. Often, removing the ability is as important as granting the ability. The political uses are as excellent as the combat tricks. Phyrexian Purge...

Here are some options: Challenging Deck - Mono-Brown Karn, Silver Golem Interesting Deck - Sydri, Galvanic Genius Vehicle Deck Synergistic - Tawnos, Urza's Apprentice Combo-y - Glissa, the Traitor Quirky - Breya, Etherium Shaper Thopter Tribal High-Power - Arcum Dagsson / Urza, Lord High Artificer

Seems interesting. I would be more directive in how you want the "pillage" to work. Example: When a "General" loses do the following (in order) - Exile all creatures and Planeswalkers that general controls to his Emporer's exile zone - Remove all remaining non-aura enchantments t...