Is a card that becomes a land a valid entry?

Does the card need to be "industry" themed or somehow related to an industry based plane?

vote: subject16, jovialjovian

Hammer of Hephaestus 1r
Sorcery (R)
Shuffle target enchantment an opponent controls into it's owner's library. It's owner creates X X/X red elementals, where X is it's converted mana cost.

Eh, I can't be the only one who doesn't subscribe to the "creature power must be expensive" camp? 40 life and the vintage cardpool say otherwise, if Derevi can be 3 mana, so can a powerful combat effect. I'm not super keen on him just being an unconditional 8 power anthem on turn three, bu...

Since its another value engine with incidental deathtouch, why not add one of the pinger equipment to really hit those rub-ins

(*I edited mine to be +6/+1, it needed to have +1 toughness being a 0/0 germ lol) Votes: netn10, subject16 Lycan-serum Dart 1r Instant (U) Deal 2 damage to target creature or player. If a creature is dealt damage this way, it becomes a Werewolf and gains "At the beginning of each upkeep, if no ...

Votes: JovialJovian, void_nothing Saberscorcher 1rr Artifact - Equipment (U) Living Weapon Equipped creature has +6/+1, haste and trample and "whenever this creature attacks, sacrifice it at the beginning of the next end step" When equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, create ...

Big fan of Xantcha, or really any other commander that isn't just free value in the command zone. Commanders that impact that gigantic life total and put aggression on the table are more interesting than the types that durdle and draw cards.

Kamahl, Fist of Krosa , Essence of the Wild Heraldic Banner , Mana Echoes Savage Beating , Shaman of Forgotten Ways , Mirrorwing Dragon / Zada, Hedron Grinder Dunno if any of these have been mentioned, but they have some game. Love the idea of using Zada or Mirrorwing on the pump strategy. SofW is ...

Lol, Whelming Wave works with Xyris. Theres no way I can not run that lol Man I really like the idea of a pump spell focused version of this list for some reason. Just feels really really fun and daring. Get as much power as you can to draw a ton of cards, use spells to give it haste and stuff. Oh m...

I love that idea, those wraths will be very effective with just one big threat on the board. I've put together a rough first draft of the deck based on what I thought and what you guys have suggested, would be keen on feedback! Currently torn on Virtus, the Veiled . My playgroup might get salty, but...

For what its worth (boy is historic forum dead) deck keeps doing well. It's currently limited by just 8 untapped white sources, so it still loses to itself, but I feel it does that less than mono blue did. Sea-Dasher Octopus *might* have game as another saboteur effect but mostly mutated as an aura,...

I dunno if I'm just missing it, but I see a lot of interest and brewing for many of the mutants, but no love for Snapdax, Apex of the Hunt , in EDH. At the time of writing EDHrec has a whopping 12 decks for him! I think people might be looking past him at the shiny "good colours" options -...

I've played multiple monarch games. Encourages aggressive play and helps punish sit back and durdle decks. Also helps the aggressive (aka "bad") colours for card advantage. Overall made the game way better, at least for us. We play at the high end of casual - not many combos, no stax, but ...

40 damage has always been the best way imo

Yeah forgot about the wraths. That became a thing pretty quickly. Overall it was pretty gross which pisses me off because I want a flicker deck but they are always either pure garbo or like this

On the upside, I guess we've found a powerful mono-white general finally =/

I played a first draft of Yorion today. Pretty much just every decent creature based flicker effect and a ton of ETB, with Panharmonicon and Eerie Interlude etc effects too. Every game lead to a delayed loop of Yorion entering on end steps and flickering a ton of junk. Loops pretty hard with any num...

In the last couple of months, I took apart my dumb fatties deck. It was Bruse Tarl, Boorish Herder + Ikra Shidiqi, the Usurper . The deck had been around in some form or another (sometimes half disassembled, but usually playable) with different colours and subthemes for maybe five years, with the ge...

Can vouch for mono-red "blink" or Boros token/blink as legit. Definitely harder to build than UWx but its also definitely way less played. Feldon is an alternative if you dont want the infinite shenanigans of Kiki-Jiki If you want to take a trip to casual-town with mono red ETB then ilhar...

Can vouch for mono-red "blink" or Boros token/blink as legit. Definitely harder to build than UWx but its also definitely way less played.

Feldon is an alternative if you dont want the infinite shenanigans of Kiki-Jiki

Man, this set has the most commander hits that I can recall in a while. Shark Typhoon is flat out amazing. Its a good card, though a bit pricy, and the cool factor is through the roof. I don't have a deck for this atm but its awesome enough that one will definitely be put together! Luminous Broodmot...

Lol thats disgusting! Friend of mine has challenged me to build land-D, and I'm a huge fan of astral slide, so maybe that commander has potential... I'm excited for some of the mutate creatures, but more the ones from Ikoria than the ones from C20. Supposedly a mutant containing a commander anywhere...

So these cards are kinda underpowered compared to other to past commanders (most of). However, i like them and i think they will help players bring new types of deck into the format Using old cards as a benchmark is the wrong way to go about it for commander imo. Its relevant for competitive format...

Best solution would have been to have a different condition on the card?

bobthefunny what's your name on Cockatrice? Mine is Maluko :) I'm usually there every night around 21:30 (Western European Time (WET)) hosting games. You can also search me by name. Unfortunately I can't use Discord :\ I'm not sure how other people do cockatrice, but my group ignores the phases and...

Timezone: NZ (+13), Keen to play during the day roughly 8AM to 8PM in the +13. Game types; I'll play anything as long as we're all on the same page. I love jank trash, tuned decks and could give cEDH a go but probably bad at it. Probably more keen on the jank end though Setup: Cockatrice + discord I...