@bravelion83 Sorry if I went out too brazenly. But since the time of our first playtest is rapidly approaching, some foreshadowing isn't necessarily that bad, eh?

Actually bravelion83 and I are like 5 months in development of a Viking set. It's bottom-up. We already have a great world and story to tell, and have just started Commons. We also have Runes, Raid and Ships ;) We even considered to actually make Kaldheim happen like what you're doing now, but decid...

A hypothetical question. How would MCC handle a new card template? Should the player provide the render then?
@void_nothing
@bravelion83

Forgotten Ruins Land (U) You may discard this card from your opening hand. If you do, draw a card at the beginning of your first upkeep. T : Add C . "Their legacy shall die by the ray of the sun and the breath of wind, but you shall not put your finger on it." —The Pale Seer, to King Euna...

Final standings:
Subject16: 20.5 + 21 + 20.5 = 62
slimytrout: 18.5 + 22 + 21 = 61.5
jamblock: 21.5 + 20.5 + 19 = 61
Kypster: 19 + 19 + 21 = 59

That was extremely close! Great work everyone! But the winner may be only one.
All hail Subject16!

Ryder (1/3) Quality - Action words should not state "you may" in the beginning. Should be worded "You may salvage a creature". (-0.5) This is templated the same way Champion is. Wren's Run Packmaster . Is there some difference between the two keywords that keeps it from working ...

1) "When you cast" is a triggered ability, Desperation is like Kicker - can't be responded to.
2) "Also" is the modern way of doing this kind of effect.

Dragoon Dive 1W Instant (C) Audacity (As you cast this spell, you may flip a coin. If you win the flip, copy this spell. If you lose the flip, counter this spell.) Target creature gets +2/+2 and gains flying until end of turn. A glorious victory or a glorious death—to the Winged Knights it matters ...

Hi @Stankweed Imp, please look at the link in @bravelion83's signature

Unfortunately I can't finish the crits today, one more day for Finals' judgements.

While February MCC is almost over, I'd like to get some feedback from you guys. Did you like it? What was good and what was bad this month?

Design time is over. Judges, you know what to do! [hr] Done Kraj's Dupe BGU Instant {C} Salvage a creature (You may exile a creature from your graveyard as you cast this spell.) Create a 1/1 green Ooze creature token with deathtouch. If a creature was salvaged, it has the toughness of that creature ...

For now I can only say it's okay. For more you need to wait for full judgement. I'll list you the options I have in mind then.

Still not good enough, slimy. -2/-2 is an offensive effect. Reflavoring Disfigure into "Warning Disfigure" does not really work. Take a look at this article . I can only say there's plenty of effects that would fit Tibalt here. So to be clear: A burn spell wouldn't be considered a defensiv...

@slimytrout Not DQable, but you would likely not get full points for the main challenge for it. Retaliation is an attack of sorts. I'm sure you'll find something more suitable in

Added clarification:

"Defensive", apart from being reactive, means "Not offensive". Simple check: Could the effect be considered an attack? The answer must be a clear "No".

finals.jpg Banner based on Time Sidewalk test card artwork by Steve Sunu and Wizards of the Coast. February MCC Final Round: Sidewalking Practice Welcome to the Fatal Four Way Final Round of this month's MCC! We've got to know your characters quite well now. They are epic, powerful and their allies...

Alright. Just as inelegant, but more balanced and correct. Sorry ForestsCarl!

The standings are pretty interesting! Unless some judge alters the scores before midnight, we're going to have a Final with FIVE players!

Ryder: ForestsCarl vs slimytrout Subject16 vs Sojourner Dusk bravelion83: Subject16 vs Sojourner Dusk jamblock vs Kypster void_nothing: jamblock vs Kypster ForestsCarl vs slimytrout Clash winners advance to the Finals. Good luck! [hr] Done Kiora, Sea Scoundrel 2(g/u)(g/u)(G/U)(G/U) Legendary Creatu...

@ForestsCarl one more day for Round 3 design

he is Rakdos from a flavor perspecitive I see no problems here. Tibalt is Rakdos, even if his existing cards are monored. Existing cards don't matter. Character concept does. Niv-Mizzet went from Blue-Red to full rainbow recently. I see no reason why Tibalt could not be Grixis or Jund once. Obvious...

round3.jpg Banner based on Soulmates test card artwork by Victoria Caña and Wizards of the Coast. February MCC Round 3: Soulmates Welcome to the third round of this month's MCC! Last round we've learned not to underestimate your characters. In fact, they're all quite epic! Now, I'm sure I'm not the...

I feel like the open ended-ness of the effect (in a 'go wide' deck this could easily be up to 5 tokens or more which is a 9 cmc Rite) and diversity of options makes up for the value. Yes, but 9cmc Rite would still be better as it doesn't merely upgrade your creatures, but produces all tokens out of...

Brackets: Ryder: Sojourner Dusk Kypster kwanyeegor-ii Henlock bravelion83: Subject16 jamblock Icarii RaikouRider void_nothing: ForestsCarl slimytrout rtk1357 Ink-Treader Top 2 from each bracket advance! [hr] Done Dack, Psychometrist [sym=ur][sym=ur] Legendary Creature — Human Wizard (M) Whenever Dac...

24-hours extension it is then.