RxPhantom wrote: ↑

1 year ago

Big obvious yay to Reanimate. Barely needs discussing.

Just one nomination a day? Come ooooooooooon! The pace...it is glacial!

For some reason I thought there was going to be three noms a day for this one. 🤷‍♂️

Elderon: A subterranean plane where time and space overlap and there's no colored mana.

Caverns of Time (Rare)
Legendary Land
t: Add c.
1, t: Exile the top card of your library. You may play that card this turn. Activate only as a sorcery.

Reanimate Yay. I mean of course. It's a no-brainer. So efficient and versatile (remember it can target creatures in opponents' yards, too), it's practically an auto-include in any Bx deck, but beyond that, it just makes sense in this deck where discarding is inevitable. Probably the herald of a sma...

DirkGently wrote: ↑

1 year ago

Hour of Devastation I think is in another league . . .

Huh?

Megiddo wrote: ↑

1 year ago

blade runner's kind of boring

After you've seen 2001: A Space Odyssey, nothing is boring.

lacramioara wrote: ↑

1 year ago

I love the Diablo series of games. But you'd have to be a complete fool not to realize that this once legendary game series has become a money-grubbing machine thanks to a publisher.

Diablo Immortal is $540,000.00 to max out.

RxPhantom wrote: ↑

1 year ago

I'll vote for the Golgari partners too. I frankly have no idea what to do with it, but I'm game.

Me neither! But that's the fun part. When I look at sayyy . . . Jared, I'm think, "I know exactly what to do with him", which defeats the purpose of this joint venture IMO.

Armix and Gilanra offer the most potential for a novel build in which the commanders are relevant.

No matter what cards come up, we can begin to solve it immediately and certainly with the internet and help from each other. So maybe instead of rerolls, we could discuss self imposed limitations per commander that could make those commanders interesting to build for. Like "no-wheels Xyris"...

Conch of the Oracle 2U
Artifact Enchantment
UU, : Look at target face-down permanent. You may turn it into the top card of your library.
Play with the top card of your library revealed.
At the beginning of each opponent's draw

Why are Make Mischief and Spawning Breath listed under "Double Your Creatures" in the OP deck list?

darrenhabib wrote: ↑

1 year ago

I don't know if this is a trick question, but there are only 8 Gideon planeswalkers.

Oh whoops I had been counting various planeswalkers and still had Chandra on the brain. Fixed in the OP.

I always wanted to make a Gideon tribal Commander deck but was waiting for there to be more Gideon walkers. Well, Gideon has been dead for awhile, leaving only 8 Gideons to work with. Which got me wondering, what's the ideal number of planeswalkers for a deck that's intended to win with them?

A note about Comprehensive Rule 108.5 has been added to Spoiler 2 of the OP. Either 108.5 was added to the Comprehensives after the OP was edited, or I just wasn't aware of it at the time. Spoiler 12 has been updated.

votes : net , kwan

Morphology (Rare)
gu
Sorcery
Each creature card in your hand perpetually gains megamorph equal to its mana cost.

iiw : subtype "Dream"

votes : cunning , net

Caldera Weird (Uncommon)
{u/r}{u/r}
Creature - Weird
1/4
Flash
Shift (You may have this creature enter the battlefield with switched power and toughness.)

iiw : subtype "Dream"

Working on an EDH deck and was curious about the interaction between Kodama of the East Tree and Recycle . Would putting a permanent onto the battlefield with the Kodama's ability cause Recycle to trigger? Back in '98, I built a deck based on Eureka + Recycle . Unfortunately, it didn't work either,...

so, last night i finally got to cast Enduring Ideal with Hive Mind on the field . . . Nice. I've often drafted suboptimal cards / strategies just for the experience of playing them (and occasionally because I had no choice 🙃). It was always so satisfying to win a game with a card that was rejected ...

so, last night i finally got to cast Enduring Ideal with Hive Mind on the field . . . Nice. I've often drafted suboptimal cards / strategies just for the experience of playing them (and occasionally because I had no choice 🙃). It was always so satisfying to win a game with a card that was rejected ...

Conch of the Oracle 2U
Artifact Enchantment
UU, T: Look at target face-down permanent. You may turn it into the

net , cunning

Bottled Lightning (Common)
{2/r}
Artifact
{2/r}, Sacrifice Bottled Lightning: It deals 3 damage to any target.

iiw : subtype "dream"

pokken wrote: ↑

1 year ago

This is going to sound pretty wild but I wouldn't mind if they thought about changing ETB effects so that they were countered if the creature wasn't still on the battlefield when they resolve

Sounds reasonable to me. Intuitive even. Would solve a lot of %$#%. I've thought this for decades. 😎

Generous Gift. It's versatile.

Played a 5 player (debatably*) casual game Tuesday in which one adult played (a fascinating yet obnoxious) Myrkul, Lord of Bones deck FULL of proxies. And I realized that in theory I'm fine with proxies, but in practice, I'm not. The game just feels hollow when played without real cards. End rant. *...

ink , kwan

Particle Accelerator (Rare)
2
Artifact
T: Add c. You may cast enchantment and sorcery spells this turn as though they had flash.

iiw : "Dream" as a subtype