Flatline , Henlock

Stone-Flowing Devils (Rare)
r
Creature - Devil
1/2
Hellbent - Cards you discard have madness 0 if you have no cards in hand.
Whenever you discard a card, Stone-Flowing Devils gets +1/-1 until end of turn.

Me when I open this thread and see the same three or four people getting mad at each other over cardboard https://media1.tenor.com/images/20ce7639bbb16a537050766660e57164/tenor.gif?itemid=3804829 I was just logging in to send out a private message to everyone in this thread that I've disagreed with...

I do understand. You seem to be approaching this from the competitive viewpoint. Most Wishing opponents do. (They just can't seem to imagine that other people have different motivations for playing and will therefore play differently then they would.) Everybody already knows that (without sideboard...

Rule 13 states that Wishes in Commander work the way that wishes work in sanctioned matches (ie. they can only get cards from your sideboard). You may want to brush up on the rules of Commander. Rule 13 does not state what you just stated, it states: "Abilities which bring card(s) you own from...

netn10 , Sagharri

Ancient Bulwark (Rare)
Land
T: Add C to your mana pool.
X, T: Target creature you control can block X additional creatures this turn. If it blocked more than one creature this turn, sacrifice it at end of turn.

Most of what you have said about the RC is derogatory in one way or another... No it isn't. And you have been trolling plenty of folks : See Spoiler X No I haven't. I just don't have time to restate everything. Some people keep pushing the same tired excuses for Rule 13 without presenting facts. My...

There are sanctioned commander matches. I know, having officiated a few myself. But it's irrelevant. Commander doesn't revolve around sanctioned/tournament play. Unsanctioned/casual is the default state of Commander, not sanctioned/tournament . Rule 13 states that Wishes in Commander work the way t...

If only there was a way to know how wishes would affect the game... Oh wait, there is: Testing? No. It was the actual rule for a while; it's what we started with and it led to lots of arguments and feelsbad moments. [mention]papa_funk[/mention]'s answer is misleading. If you look into the history o...

folding_music , shukkets

Mind Tongs (Uncommon)
2
Artifact - Equipment
Whenever equipped creature deals combat damage to a player, search their library for a card and exile it. Then they shuffle their library.
Equip 2

Flatline , netn10

Dragonspine (Uncommon)
2
Legendary Artifact - Equipment
Equipped creature gets +2/+1
Whenever Dragonspine levels up, attach it to a creature you control.
Level up t
LEVEL 3-4
Equipped creature gets +4/+2.
LEVEL 5+
Equipped creature gets +6/+3

Snes wrote: ↑

4 years ago

*snip*

What makes it acceptable to include Godhead of Awe in a mono white Commander deck but not to include Absorb and Mortify in the same deck?

I propose that the philosophy should be "Commander decks should have no mana costs that can't be paid using colors of mana in the commander's color identity." This keeps the intended restriction of making the commander's colors matter, without arbitrarily shutting out hybrid costs. I actu...

Wizyard , Bravelion

Phyrexian Procession
2B
Enchantment
Whenever a tapped creature you control dies, exile it and return a creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield tapped.

Slimytrout , starjake

Tomb Tiller (Uncommon)
2
Artifact
2, t, Put the top two cards of your library into your graveyard: Shuffle your graveyard, then return the top card of your graveyard to your hand.

IIW: casting coat of two or more different hybrids

Annihilator... still too early?

Krishnath , Raptorchan

Diamond Golem (Common)
5
Artifact Creature - Golem
1/1
Indestructible

IIW: a card with a planeswalker subtype* in its rules text
*(not a planeswalker card name)

Only because you consider rule 13 an errata but not rule 4. Both of them [Wishes and Battle of Wits ] don't function in commander. Comparing Rule 13 to any other rule of Commander is a false analogy. Format defining rules are not the same as a rule that redefines a subset of cards. Limited deck siz...

The problem with banning them is having to ban every single new mechanic that pulls stuff from outside of the game. It's not a reasonable default position, and would require lots of gymnastics. You wind up having to ban some of them but not all of them, vs. just disabling the mechanic. Golden Wish ...

Myr Enforcer Was a four-of in every Standard Affinity Deck 2004-5. A multifaceted deck that could consistently win on turn 3-5 in Standard.

The problem with banning them is having to ban every single new mechanic that pulls stuff from outside of the game. It's not a reasonable default position, and would require lots of gymnastics. You wind up having to ban some of them but not all of them, vs. just disabling the mechanic. Golden Wish ...

Man, these are all so good! But there can only be two: void_nothing (clever for not mattering in Commander (were they to function)) folding_music (unique as a janky Jonny/Jenny wish) Unlimited Power (Rare) XX Sorcery Target creature gets +X/+X and gains annihilator X until end of turn. (Whenever it ...

Flatline, Marioguy3

Arak, the Runehearted (Mythic)
{g/w}{u/b}
Legendary Creature - Elder Human
2/2
Flash
When Arak, the Runehearted leaves the battlefield, shuffle all Auras attached to it into your library, then draw that many cards.

Sheldon wrote: ↑

4 years ago

on what turn do you think it's reasonable to end a game?

11

folding_music , Sagharri Four-Armed Cyclops (Rare) 2RG Creature — Cyclops 4/4 Menace Four-Armed Cyclops can block an additional creature each combat. Heroic — Whenever you cast a spell that targets Four-Armed Cyclops, it fights target creature you don't control. (Each deals damage equal to its power...

Henlock , emily (though haste should be menace) Skane, Apostate Healer (Mythic) 2UBR Legendary Creature — Nightmare Cleric 6/2 Flying, haste, afflict 4 (Whenever this creature becomes blocked, defending player loses 4 life.) Whenever an opponent becomes afflicted by Skane, Apostate Healer or another...

slimytrout , starjake

Wish Upon a Star (Mythic)
1w
Sorcery
You may choose a legendary card you own from outside the game, reveal that card, and put it into your hand. Exile Wish Upon a Star.

IIW: defender and haste on the same card