void_nothing wrote: ↑

4 years ago

Don't see why not considering offering reduces costs by mana costs.

Is it required for the reminder text to include "Mana cost includes color."?

Recall is a mix of flashback and emerge . My question is, must the cost reduction only check converted mana cost or is it okay for it to include colors? Why or why not? Rejection (Common) 3U Instant Return target nonland permanent to its owner's hand. Recall 5U (Whenever a creature enters the battle...

Kwanyeegor , Henlock

Long Live the Queen (Rare)
3w
Enchantment
Flash
As long as you're the monarch, you have hexproof.
Whenever you gain life, you become the monarch.

IIW: cards for commander

(...I only ever drew parallels to cEDH and never actually talked about it directly...) What's the difference? Especially when it's been obvious since your first post (you were in fact the first respondent in this thread) that your thesis and everything that has followed, no matter how well stated, ...

Rithaniel , emily , HM Flatline , RattingRote

Demonic Tutorial (Mythic)
bbb
Tribal Enchantment - Demon
Whenever you cast Demonic Tutorial or another Demon spell, search your library for a card, put that card into your hand, then shuffle your library.

emily , Netn10 (though it should be uncommon and would make a cool Fortification)

Sparkeater (Uncommon)
2r
Creature - Elemental Hound
2/2
Haste, protection from planeswalkers
Whenever one or more loyalty counters is removed from a planeswalker, put that many +1/+1 counters on Sparkeater.

I think that R&D is moving in the direction of making cards like new Karn that reference both outside the game and exile, which might make the point moot (especially if they errata the old cards to match, although I doubt they have any interest in doing so, and understandably). I've considered ...

Shukkets , Bravelion

Consuming Darkness (Common)
3B
Instant
Exile target creature.
Foretell B (As you draw this card, you may pay B and play with it revealed.)
When you foretell this card, exile target enchantment an opponent controls.

Bravenothing , void_lion

Mindstorm (Uncommon)
u
Instant
Target player draws a card.
Storm (When you cast this spell, copy it for each spell cast before it this turn. You may choose new targets for the copies.)

Flatline , Netn10

Dirty Politics (Rare)
4B
Sorcery
Each DCC player with the most points loses X points, where X is the number of votes this card gets.

RattingRots , Bravelion

Split Lightning (Common, for a commander product)
2R
Sorcery
Split Lightning deals 2 damage to any target.
Conquest (Copy this spell for each player you attacked this turn. You may choose new targets for the copies.)

That's a fine and dandy assumption based on subjective experience. Please be more specific. I see subjective experience in my post (My attendence this weekend), but what assumption are you referring to? That changing the rules is a nonstarter? Uh, wait a second, No wonder you were confused. I am to...

*snip* An appeal to authority and a few quips like "Your points aren't relevant", "I didn't use the word 'confusing'", and "I lol at you". It sounds like you're out of steam. I'm going to go back and give your OP in this thread the attention it deserved. I think everyt...

Bravelion , folding_music

Reinvent (Rare)
u
Instant
Exile target permanent, then return it to the battlefield under its owner's control as a copy of another permanent that shares a type with it. (Artifact, creature, enchantment, land, and planeswalker are types of permanents.)

That's a fine and dandy assumption based on subjective experience. I don't expect you to quote my entire previous reply or to answer every sentence, but you sure are ignoring a whole lot of reality (again). So I ask again with emphasis added: You claim that it would confuse players for Wishing to fu...

I especially like Ravenous. imo it would fit best in Jund. It's likely that Wizards would limit the sacrifice it to nonland permanents because new players would wind up mana screwing themselves, resulting in unfun play and a reduced chance that they'll keep playing. Emerge serves as a good prototype...

RattingRots , emily

Rule Thirteen (Rare)
0
Conspiracy
(Start the game with this conspiracy face up in the command zone.)
Before each game starts, choose an effect.
The chosen effect does not function.

In casual games outside of sanctioned tournaments, with Living Wish you can choose any "creature or land card you own from outside the game"; the comprehensive rules do not limit this choice depending on how many cards with the same name as that card are in your deck (review C.R. 400.10)....

In casual games outside of sanctioned tournaments, with Living Wish you can choose any "creature or land card you own from outside the game"; the comprehensive rules do not limit this choice depending on how many cards with the same name as that card are in your deck (review C.R. 400.10)....

The official Magic rules on wishing have not changed since 2002 Regardless of what was official, players had all kinds of their own ideas about how to Wish well after 2002. The vast majority of players at that time (if not now) didn't play sanctioned games. They played unsanctioned, casual games an...

If a player has four copies of Taiga in their deck, can they Living Wish for a fifth copy of Taiga in an unsanctioned, casual game of Legacy?

Bravelion, Marioguy3 Endless Genesis (Mythic) 4U Instant Kicker 2U (You may pay an additional 4U as you cast this spell.) Create a token that's a copy of target creature. If Endless Genesis was kicked, it gains epic. (For the rest of the game, you can't cast spells. At the beginning of each of your ...

Flatline , netn10

Hagatha Drood (Rare)
gwub
Legendary Creature - Hag
3/6
Lifelink, deathtouch
Whenever you gain life, scry that many cards.

Flatline , emily

Endless War
1ur
Sorcery
Raid - If you attacked with a creature this turn, take an extra turn after this one. Exile Endless War.

The "cretinous" comment was supposed to be silly not serious. How is wishing fundamentally different now than it was in 2002? Wishes had no Commander-specific rules up until at least 2010 That's all I got. I had an actual answer but lost it to the aether and currently don't have the energy...