MTGNexus

Well, first off, "mill", "discard", "tap", and others are keyword actions rather than keywords, and more than that, they're essentially evergreen - in fact, they appear more than most evergreen keywords do.

As stated in the thread, I've listed all of the valid choices of keywords to use in the clarifications.

Just to inform you: this challenge includes consecutive mana VALUES, not costs. The original post is fixed.

January CCL poll is up.

@OneAndOnly @shullz as far as I know, "above" means "higher than you in the list", not lower.

Raptorchan wrote: ↑

3 months ago

@OneAndOnly @shullz as far as I know, "above" means "higher than you in the list", not lower.

You're right. I just did the same thing as last time. I'll change it.

I just decided what they hey, I'll critique everyone's submittals. I only ranked the six above me, and only top-three'd the ones I thought were top-three worthy.

One day left to vote in January Final Poll.

@void_nothing wins the January CCL!

February CCL top 4 and March CCL round 1 will both come tomorrow. Time has gotten away from me.

Can the tokens generated for the CCL 1/1 real world animals be more than one kind. Such as an animal version of Sarpadian Empires, Vol. VII or A Killer Among Us (I'm not planing on that kind of card. I have something else in mind.)

Komandon wrote: ↑

2 months ago

Can the tokens generated for the CCL 1/1 real world animals be more than one kind. Such as an animal version of Sarpadian Empires, Vol. VII or A Killer Among Us (I'm not planing on that kind of card. I have something else in mind.)

Yes, that fits the challenge just fine.

Now putting out the call for a host for the April CCL!

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3?

AnotherAlias wrote: ↑

1 month ago

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3?

No, absolutely not. The brackets are there to determine who can score points from whom and give everyone a shot.

void_nothing wrote: ↑

1 month ago

AnotherAlias wrote: ↑

1 month ago

@void_nothing, is one allowed to put a player they do not evaluate in their top 3?

No, absolutely not. The brackets are there to determine who can score points from whom and give everyone a shot.

Thank you. That's what I thought, but it's good to have confirmation before I call out another user.

@marioguy3, as void_nothing stated above, you cannot have Komandon in your top 3 for round 2. (Those above you on the list (looping to the bottom) were: netn10, shullz, Raptorchan, OneAndOnly, Henlock, and AnotherAlias.)

void_nothing wrote: ↑

1 month ago

Now putting out the call for a host for the April CCL!

And I will heed, if I am allowed to.

Lorn Asbord Schutta wrote: ↑

1 month ago

void_nothing wrote: ↑

1 month ago

Now putting out the call for a host for the April CCL!

And I will heed, if I am allowed to.

More than that, you're welcome to. It's good to have you back and I'll put your name down.

@AnotherAlias Thank you for mentioning that. True mistake. Fixed.

@Komandon, same thing applies to you. You cannot have me in your top 3 because I was not one of the six above you. (Your list was meant to be: marioguy3, netn10, shullz, Raptorchan, OneAndOnly, and Henlock.)

@AnotherAlias I see I looped wrong. I skipped Henlock by accident and did you who is below me.

I'm going to remove my post with a place holder and cut/paste in a note file on my phone for now.

Hopefully the confusion about first and second round judging has now been cleared up. Remember that you should always evaluate the contestants below you on the list for round 1 and above you on the list for round 2! On that note, I'll be posting the next round of the March CCL tomorrow - sorry for the delay on my end.

@Raptorchan Congratulations on the win in February!

Quick question: Does a permanent that returns itself count for the challenge?

Henlock wrote: ↑

1 month ago

Quick question: Does a permanent that returns itself count for the challenge?

I'll say yes it does.

@void_nothing, exiling a (permanent) card from a graveyard, then returning that to the battlefield doesn't count, right? Also, does cloaking/manifesting a card in a graveyard count?