cfusionpm wrote: ↑
8 months ago
drmarkb wrote: ↑
8 months ago
None are relevant. It is gone. It is not coming back.
Remember when people said that about Jace? And Stoneforge?
My whole post was irrelevant to Modern. As was yours-
One of those topics did, and could, exist in Modern, and was a series of broader looks at banlist criteria for our format. One of them discusses a format that for all practical purposes does not exist in paper and is crippled by a Reserve List that makes playing it legitimately prohibitively expensive.
You clearly don't seem to care about the 'why' so maybe just ignore it and bring up other topics to discuss?
I answered why people keep going on about Twin, which was your question. Your only question in a one line post, iirc. It is there two pages back.
In that I put a one line aside in my longer post that bolt snap bolt exists elsewhere in another format and is popular.
The rest was, as usual, Twin talk, about why people won't let it go- your question.
I love the idea that paper Legacy does not exist, but will drop it. As you suggest.
How about a challenge for you. The next time someone discusses the current
ban list you don't (a) refer to wotc having no logic in their ban list or how they just ban what they feel like and (b) when someone posts something you don't agree with about Twin you don't respond, because I think if you don't respond to it the thread won't be endless repetition.
If someone has not been convinced by any of your arguments about Twin yet, they never will be.
And in answer to your point about Jace, SFM. The answer is no I don't. You can't return to a format if you have never been in it. I know what you mean, of course.