Cards that should be reprinted to enter the Modern card pool

[Amalek0]

counterspell
gerrard's verdict
vindicate
innocent blood
undermine
recoil
containment priest
propaganda
council's judgment
enchantress's presence

[The Fluff]

Armory Automaton looks like it's fun to use as a single in sfm decks, or simple decks with plenty of equipments.

[fourdogsinahorsesuit]

Abolish the reserved list and free Phyrexian Dreadnought

[The Fluff]

Sunstrike Legionnaire reprint please. Need him for a combo.

[The Fluff]

Once again, I request terravore. Give ponza a little more power.

Also spinning darkness, one more life gain for mono black.

[The Fluff]

Would crystal vein be too good for modern?

[AvalonAurora]

Would crystal vein be too good for modern?

Almost certainly, especially as long as Tron and Eldrazi Temple are legal.

[AvalonAurora]

A quick look at some of the stuff from Jumpstart that isn't modern legal that I or others haven't been commonly listing that seems like it could maybe see some theoretical modern use, if nothing else, in some budget decks perhaps, or some weird future fringe cases reliant on theoretical future cards.

Archaeomender
Blessed Sanctuary
Branching Evolution
Brindle Shoat
Bruvac the Grandiloquent
Duelist's Heritage
Herald's Horn
Kels, Fight Fixer
Lightning Phoenix
Ormos, Archive Keeper
Release the Dogs
Scholar of the Lost Trove
Thriving Bluff
Thriving Grove
Thriving Heath
Thriving Isle
Thriving Moor
Tinybones, Trinket Thief
Witch of the Moors

[Feyd_Ruin]

Lin Sivvi, Defiant Hero, Defiant Falcon, and Ramosian Sergeant. Hopefully in Modern Horizons 2, where they also create new rebels. I would LOVE modern Rebels. I don't care if it doesn't win, it would be fun and nostalgic.

[Krishnath]

Lin Sivvi, Defiant Hero, Defiant Falcon, and Ramosian Sergeant. Hopefully in Modern Horizons 2, where they also create new rebels. I would LOVE modern Rebels. I don't care if it doesn't win, it would be fun and nostalgic.

Lin Sivvi is kinda broken though, got banned from standard when Masques was legal. But I will freely admit that I like the card, and I always feel sad that Rebels got a legendary creature, but Mercenaries haven't gotten one (yet).

[The Fluff]

I still remember the mono white rebels my cousin had, almost the entire deck are rebels. Was new to mtg during those times, and all my decks got totally trounced on by that deck. However, the power level of mtg cards has gone up through the years.. maybe Lin-sivvi would be a normal powered card now instead of broken. Stoneforge Mystic was not really strong in standard when all she could fetch is a basilisk collar. Sivvi would be under control if the rebels she could fetch are not too strong.

[Card Slinger J]

Hmm let's see:

Stifle
Mana Echoes
Patriarch's Bidding
Chain of Vapor
Brightstone Ritual
Wirewood Herald
Chain of Smog
Wirewood Pride
Cabal Coffers
Morningtide
Tainted Pact
Extract
Patron Wizard
Mindslicer
Price of Glory
Entomb
Shadowmage Infiltrator
Fire // Ice
Lightning Angel
Orim's Chant
Warped Devotion
Sterling Grove
Empress Galina
Tangle
Spreading Plague
Lobotomy
Phyrexian Infiltrator
Rootwater Thief
Flame Rift
Soothsaying
Food Chain
Fountain Watch

[folding_music]

god, I wonder if the price of Food Chain would go up or down if they reprinted it? it's soooo broken
I used to have four of them when they were a 50p rare. Lion's Eye Diamonds and Survivals of the Fittest too. I threw away so much money now that I think about it...

[Feyd_Ruin]

Lin Sivvi is kinda broken though, got banned from standard when Masques was legal. But I will freely admit that I like the card, and I always feel sad that Rebels got a legendary creature, but Mercenaries haven't gotten one (yet).

For the time and format, sure. But compared to everything currently in modern? She might show up, but still be outclassed.

[Krishnath]

Lin Sivvi is kinda broken though, got banned from standard when Masques was legal. But I will freely admit that I like the card, and I always feel sad that Rebels got a legendary creature, but Mercenaries haven't gotten one (yet).

For the time and format, sure. But compared to everything currently in modern? She might show up, but still be outclassed.

I think you severely underestimate how good Sivvi Rebels was. At the time you either played that deck, or you lost. Nothing could stand up to it. The rebel recursion plus the ability to fetch them is what does it, and remember, she can fetch Changelings as well. Like the 3/3 double striker...

[The Fluff]

@folding_music

anything that get reprinted would go down in price.

anyway, Foodchain, LED and Survival are legacy power level cards. Wotc would never reprint them in a modern horizons set.

@Card Slinger J

a lot of those cards you mentioned looked fine, Fire and Ice, Sterling Grove seems usable for some decks.

although entomb and foodchain are probably too strong here.

[The Fluff]

since old cards were mention. Also thinking if some thrulls like Thrull Champion and Breeding Pit + some support cards to be reprinted, so we could have another tribe to play with.

[The Fluff]

How about Harsh mercy? It's another card that tribal decks can use.

[The Fluff]

once more, asking for Terravore..

[motleyslayer]

once more, asking for Terravore..

after thinking more, that would be cool in ponza lists

after playing with it in historic, Phyrexian Tower would be fun in modern

[The Fluff]

yeah, would cool in Ponza. Actually, the reason I was asking for it is because I own a Ponza deck in modern. Have been active in the Ponza thread at salvation.

Phyrexian Tower? Out of curiosity.. what deck do you plan to put that in?

[motleyslayer]

yeah, would cool in Ponza. Actually, the reason I was asking for it is because I own a Ponza deck in modern. Have been active in the Ponza thread at salvation.

Phyrexian Tower? Out of curiosity.. what deck do you plan to put that in?

I don't even know what modern deck I'd play it in, let alone what wants it. I just find it a cool card

[TheAmericanSpirit]

Please reprint Phyrexian Walker so I can block the stupid monkey.

[The Fluff]

phyrexian war going on now... it's the perfect time to reprint the walker.

yeah, 3 toughness allows him to block monkeh.