In general, you need to obey as many requirements as possible without breaking any restrictions. So, you will just choose one of them to attack since they can only attack alone. You do need to attack with at least one, but you won't be able to attack with both due to their own restriction. Note that...

It is effectively the second option. Mill, as opposed to drawing cards, is one complete action. So, if Tome Scour is cast (ignoring the fact that it is a Sorcery; I just wanted a mill card referenced), that is one event of "Mill 5 cards". So, the entire event takes place, as modified by th...

Unless I am misunderstanding what you are trying to do, there is no special interaction here. You use Avatar of Hope to block 5 creatures. You then use the Banding creature to block one of the same creatures as the Avatar. For that attacking creature, and that creature only (since it is the only one...

I am with Mookie on the Wrath of God debate. I play White in more decks than any other color and I usually have a fair amount of wraths in general. And I haven't played Wrath of God in a deck in years. White just has so many other options that WOG doesn't make the cut in most cases. As mentioned tho...

You will be able to do both effects. As the Clone enters, you do its own Replacement Effect. Once that applies, the game then checks to see if any other Replacement Effects should apply. And there is: Rex's own effect so you will get to do that effect now. 616.1c. If any of the replacement and/or pr...

@TheAmericanSpirit

Thanks for the catch. Corrected that in my original comment to hopefully lessen confusion going forward. Totally my own fault for just forgetting which Odric I was looking at

It is worth pointing out that Knight of Malice will grant Indominus Rex, Alpha "Hexproof from White", not the Hexproof ability as a whole. When dealing with cards like this, the specific variant is what is granted. Rule 122.1b allows for Keyword counters for the Variants and the Card Rulin...

Now, with all of that being said, I will offer the same caveat that I would have offered in the Judge Chat whenever a Panglacial Wurm question came up: scenarios with Panglacial Wurm aren't really really scenarios and aren't really worth diving into too deeply to get a real answer. They are theoryc...

edit: okay, so possibly this does not work: 500.3. A step in which no players receive priority ends when all specified actions that take place during that step are completed. The only such steps are the untap step (see rule 502) and certain cleanup steps (see rule 514). So that would imply that, wh...

@WizardMN I guess that makes sense, I still don't like that the same words can effect different sets of things though. If you wanted to remake Kardur to only effect things currently on-board, how would that work? "Each creature your opponents control"? I had intuited that putting the timi...

@Mookie I understand all of that quite well, I'm just saying that if the technology exists for Kardur to work the way he does, I see no reason it couldn't work for an instant version of Dress Down. If Kardur was worded "until your next turn, your opponents must attack with all their creatures....

If I have Ojer and Torbran out and I deal non combat damage to my opponent, will they take 4 or 6? Both Ojer and Torbran are replacement effects, so you can choose the order in which they apply. If you apply Ojer first, you'll deal 6 damage. If you apply Torbran first, you'll deal 4 damage. It is w...

Seems vague (where is the line where you can still recognize the art?) and unnecessary, but I haven't played in a tournament in years, and never a tournament big enough to worry about enforcing rules like these. This would be a judgment call for the head judge but, to be honest, I think it is the m...

Just got some alters I ordered in the mail, the person is new to mtg alters, had done only a couple of lands before. I think they are pretty cool. unfurtonately she covered the names but It's not like a big deal I think. If I get to I'll post them later here I assume you are running them primarily ...

If you play the deck and 34 is often enough, then I say go for it. I know everyone has their own ideas but you can probably play it as is and tweak the land count as you go if you feel you need to. That is a good point on Bloom Tender. I was figuring that it would normally be 2 mana so it might be w...

If you want the deck header to match your decks colors, you can just do this in the deck tag: [deck="The Trudge Cafe" style="Golgari" view="list" shadow="2" order="fixed"] This gets you this: Commander 1 Gyome, Master Chef Notice that the "style...

plus there are some cards (like counterspells and X spells) that get negated entirely. While it basically does negate counterspells, it doesn't do as much to X spells. This is because it doesn't have them recast the spell. It puts it onto the stack as a copy of the original spell. And X is copied i...

I am going to try out these changes CUTS 1 Sheoldred, Whispering One 1 Teferi's Puzzle Box 1 Psychosis Crawler ADDS 1 Throne of Eldraine 1 Bloodchief Ascension 1 Polluted Bonds I decided I wanted to move into trying to do a few more drain effects similar to Painful Quandary. I think I like the idea ...

I am going to try out these changes CUTS 1 Mire in Misery ADDS 1 Rankle's Prank There aren't really any cards that I look at and see as being bad or needing to be replaced. Which is good in a sense as it means that, for the most part, the list is in a good spot. But it does make it tough to find cut...

I have decided to try out these following changes CUTS 1 Anointed Procession 1 Glimpse of Tomorrow ADDS 1 Mondrak, Glory Dominus 1 Court of Ardenvale I generally prefer creatures over other permanents (other than lands) so I think adding in Mondrak over Procession makes sense. Court is a good option...

I may have missed something but I was unable to find anything in Wilds of Eldraine or the Commander decks that I felt would be a good fit for this deck. Hopefully the next set offers something.

Here are my thoughts regarding Wilds of Eldraine and the Wilds of Eldraine Commander set: Black Cards Throne of Eldraine - This seems like it should be home in a lot of mono-colored decks and I think it fits here. 5 mana is a tall order but providing 4 mana right away means it is a net cost of 1 pot...

Here are my thoughts regarding Wilds of Eldraine and the Wilds of Eldraine Commander set: Red Cards Goddric, Cloaked Reveler - A cheap-ish Legendary that can be a big beater is a decent option. But, that is really all he is is just a big beater and I am not sure it is that great here. Once I hit the...

Here are my thoughts regarding Wilds of Eldraine and the Wilds of Eldraine Commander set: Black Cards Rankle's Prank - I think a card with Rankle's name on it deserves a look just for that. And the third ability especially is one that I am most interested in, though the second ability can be useful ...

Here are my thoughts regarding Wilds of Eldraine and the Wilds of Eldraine Commander set: White Cards Court of Ardenvale - This could be a good resurrection option as well as a good card draw option. And with the amount of fliers this deck should have, it shouldn't be too tough to regain the Monarch...