Search found 35 matches

by TheTuna
1 year ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Unreleased and New Card Discussion
Replies: 9546
Views: 646990

Re: Unreleased and New Card Discussion

Resplendent Angel reprint or bust!
by TheTuna
1 year ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Unreleased and New Card Discussion
Replies: 9546
Views: 646990

Re: Unreleased and New Card Discussion

NZB2323 wrote:
1 year ago
I know they're not from the same plane, but I would have loved to see Thalia, Guardian of Thraben combined with Ruric Thar, the Unbowed.
Oh man, that's evil. I love it! We can dream.
by TheTuna
1 year ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Let's Brew Thalia and The Gitrog Monster: Man I Love Frogs
Replies: 82
Views: 4600

Re: Let's Brew Thalia and The Gitrog Monster: Man I Love Frogs

Very cool to see the brewing with this! As a huge fan of Thalia, I'm pretty excited given that her prior cards aren't super compelling as a commander. If it's a question of mana sinks, what about Luminarch Ascension ? Thalia/Gitrog being a first strike deathtouch might make it significantly easier t...
by TheTuna
1 year ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

To your last point, if you printed "Worse Aura Blast - 1RR - Instant: Destroy target enchantment", that would be absolutely unplayably bad by W standards and you would never see it in any WR deck, but mono-R decks would consider running it, because mono-R is really really really bad at de...
by TheTuna
1 year ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

First, my point is that I don't think Sanctuary Warden is exciting because I want more than a two-turn Divination before we're leveraging 6-mana spells. I'm not saying that a card with 6 mana value has to be backbreaking, but it can't be "draw 2, but slowly". I'm not even saying "you...
by TheTuna
1 year ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

Sanctuary Warden in particular is a pretty nice draw source in that it natively has "draw 2" stapled to it without requiring you to jump through really any hoops at all. If W keeps getting more cards like that, the color will be in good shape. Sanctuary Warden is 6 mana, mate. I would lik...
by TheTuna
1 year ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

Welp, that's it for me. White is truly never going to catch up. "We don't want to take away space from other colours", ok, so, why is blue allowed to get Ravenform and Hullbreacher , Simic got Oversimplify , black got Opposition Agent (take that, Aven Mindcensor), and green got basically ...
by TheTuna
2 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

I would disagree with this, personally. I don't think G having Craterhoof or U having Expropriate and Cyclonic Rift has made their average game worse. This isn't about giving W an edge over the other colors with some tool they don't have, just about giving W a couple more more high-value "clos...
by TheTuna
2 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

Lol those are so insanely broken. 6 mana destroy all enemy lands as an instant? You think 9 mana destroy all enemy permanents is LESS reliable than expropriate? I mean I hate expropriate too but it's not THAT stupid. Y'all in here trying to make white the "kill on sight" color lmao. Those...
by TheTuna
2 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

Feels like the last area remaining to address is the need for powerful game-closing high-CMC effects. If you're speaking about wincons in general, white has quite a number of them available, from Approach of the Second Sun to Faithbound Judge to Halo Fountain and more. Admittedly, each tends to nee...
by TheTuna
2 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Is White getting better?
Replies: 164
Views: 11207

Re: Is White getting better?

As Josh Lee Kwai observed a while back on Twitter during the conversation around I think Opposition Agent, W doesn't just need to get really good cards, it needs to get them at a higher rate than the other colors, in order to close the gap. I've been dubious about WotC's efforts to fix W for a while...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Speculation
Topic: MtG Netflix Series Speculation.
Replies: 21
Views: 7393

Re: MtG Netflix Series Speculation.

do we know what planeswalkers or plane it will be on? I imagine the core Gatewatch are all a safe lock, as they've been prominent in MtG marketing materials for years. Teferi seems like a good choice as well, as he can play more of a mentor role. Plane-wise, probably MtG planes that are both unique...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Rule Change Ideas - SCG article
Replies: 63
Views: 6828

Re: Rule Change Ideas - SCG article

I normally agree with what Maro says, but I think he's way off base on hybrid mana in Commander. A card like Divinity of Pride is very clearly both a white and a black card based off the literal color of the cardboard itself, so why should I be able to play it in my mono-White deck that's not allowe...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: The moving goalposts of staying within budget
Replies: 21
Views: 2736

Re: The moving goalposts of staying within budget

Short of going full konami (and you never go full konami...) this wont help. It wont help until r/mtgfinance stops playing magical stocks. People speculating on Magic rubs me the wrong way as well, but I very much doubt that they're primarily responsible for the massive spikes behind cards like Exp...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Rules and Philosophy
Topic: [MCD] Cheap Tutors
Replies: 26
Views: 4052

Re: [MCD] Cheap Tutors

I do agree that tutors feel quite problematic in that they promote extremely repetitive play, which cuts against the core of a 100-card singleton format: high variance. The presence versus absence of tutors in any given deck contributes heavily to power imbalances, as well. If I have 2-5 ways to tut...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: The moving goalposts of staying within budget
Replies: 21
Views: 2736

Re: The moving goalposts of staying within budget

The simple fact is that Wizards is not reprinting Commander-focused cards enough to keep up with the insane increase in the format's popularity over the last few years. The prices for Cyclonic Rift, Teferi's Protection, and Expropriate alone, all played only in Commander, speak volumes on this subje...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Commander 2019 Speculation
Replies: 74
Views: 8744

Re: Commander 2019 Speculation

I really would like to see another range of partner commanders but they need to tweak the rule a bit. Maybe errata partner to say: Partner (You can have two commanders if both have partner and both have the same expansion symbol) Or something to that effect, I'm not a game designer! For my money, &...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Anti-Spike police / counterspell density
Replies: 12
Views: 2111

Re: Anti-Spike police / counterspell density

If you really want to hose people who rely on casting stuff for free or off stuff like Mana Crypt early game, there's always Lavinia, Azorius Renegade . I've been meaning to build her as a "degeneracy police" (without any lockouts) myself. She doesn't do much against Titania, though. She's...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: What Makes Bad Games?
Replies: 107
Views: 14794

Re: What Makes Bad Games?

Fundamentally, what makes for a bad game of EDH is feeling like I didn't get to play a game of Magic with my deck. This feeling can be attributed to a few main causes: Decks/players winning way too quickly: When I sit down for a game of Commander, I (and, I suspect, probably the majority of the play...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Changing your deck's power level without changing cards
Replies: 18
Views: 3491

Re: Changing your deck's power level without changing cards

One can also favor card draw over tutoring to increase variance, and/or make sure loops require a minimum number of cards to assemble. Absolutely this. The power gap between a deck running a tutor suite and a deck with no tutors at all is typically quite vast, so if your playgroup doesn't like tuto...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Commander 2019 Speculation
Replies: 74
Views: 8744

Re: Commander 2019 Speculation

I'm hoping the morph deck is Sultai, then my Storrev deck has a reasonable chance of picking up some new toys. Won't lie, I'm a bit bamboozled as to how you base a deck around flashback. Dragonlover Madness seems even trickier than Flashback. Madness feels like it has very few existing cards which ...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Having Your Voice Heard
Replies: 354
Views: 43499

Re: Having Your Voice Heard

Posting news to /r/EDH is a fine idea, but beyond that, I doubt if there's much to be gained by directly engaging the community there. Even by Reddit (and, what's more, by MtG Reddit) standards it's thoroughly toxic and very, very Spikey. Casual players' voices get drowned out very consistently on t...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Commander 2019 Speculation
Replies: 74
Views: 8744

Re: Commander 2019 Speculation

I expect to pick up the full set this year as well. Might even get two, one to crack for parts and the other one to keep playable as-is. Precon-level Commander has made for some of my favorite and most memorable games. I hope the recent comments by WotC about the reprint value being such crap last y...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Commander 2019 Speculation
Replies: 74
Views: 8744

Re: Commander 2019 Speculation

looks like there is a leak of the themes here from a European distributor: https://www.blackfire.eu/product.php?id=33368 Themes on keywords: populate, morph, flashback and madness. Huh, not sure if I buy it, but that's interesting. Populate is probably the most personally interesting for me. Not su...
by TheTuna
4 years ago
Forum: Commander
Topic: Commander 2019 Speculation
Replies: 74
Views: 8744

Re: Commander 2019 Speculation

Suncleanser from Core Set 2019 is actually a pretty brutal hoser for any experience counter general. I certainly wouldn't be opposed to more, though.

Go to advanced search