I have to agree that I'm a little thrown off by the set. It seems to be doing things that aren't very MtG to me. The companion mechanic is just …….out there....can't be balanced much either Mutate Seems sloppy, the counters seems sloppy. The paper board states are going to look ridiculous. I also am...

Interesting,... haste is not on the list.

Interesting April Fools Article....hmm..?

The point of the game is to play and have fun, especially in a casual, social format like Commander. People who don't have as much money should be able to play as well, just like how you don't need to spend a lot of money to play chess, bridge, or connect 4, you shouldn't need to spend a lot of mon...

Its almost impossible to not now think of the Guild for these. The names seem perfect.
That would be weird...….

Wonder if they would work in our casual Wizards Tower games ever so often. Maybe a once of for fun multiplayer

I like the cards, I guess I like the charitable aspect, I am ….indifferent? on the agenda of it. Box Toppers are kinda cool. Trying to rationalize $25 for the charity and $25 for the product feels slightly dirty. Secret Lairs themselves. I appears? they are here to stay and will be fairly regular. I...

Yup, those are bad. Not even that great of art. Love how you don't even get to see the cards until you wait in the que, then you have only 10 minutes to order. :laughing:

Since June 8, 2018 (20 months ago) and upcoming........... Battlebond M19 Commander 2018 Guilds of Ravnica Ultimate Masters Ravnica Allegiance War of the Spark Modern Horizons 1 Commander 2019 Throne of Eldraine 7 Secret Lairs Theros Beyond Secret Lair Rats 5 Secret Lairs Unsanctioned Ikoria Ikoria ...

So......
Eldrazi imprisoned (they got out)
Emrakul imprisoned (by her own accord)
Bolas imprisoned (he'll get out one day)
Heliod imprisoned (until he does 4 things)

Gotta leave those threads loose...........

I just don't get the lore on this....... Is he a planeswalker?? The blurb says something must happen to ingnite his spark??? What the hell does that mean. Is he sparked or not? Is it a real person or a created one? Oh and shout out to another non-human planeswalker :sick: I guess we wouldn't have id...

So awesome in every way...............except.......a better worded Card Name.
"Kiora Bests the Sea God" seems juvenille or ......just.... not...... eloquent enough i guess.
I can't think of anything better but for a Card I want to see and use, I hate the name.

Where is the Art direction for Elspeth's face coming from. Both of these new cards......and the trailer.....ugh

I forgot the Planeswalkers had alt arts in Eldraine..........duh.

Well.
Confused as to where these Marble statue alt arts will show up (non-foil alt art??)??
Elspeth art is not that great (on either card)
Ashiok seems annoyingly fun.
Pokemon Energy are just that.

If putting keyword counters are the "crazy new big deal" I'll be pretty unimpressed. Its basically not a new thing, we have plenty of cards (spells, creatures, pretty much everything) that grant keywords. Just because I can put a paper counter on it seems pretty lame. It sounds like a &quo...

and Magic begins jumping shark
All the overload of products, specialties everywhere, bans and new formats disrupting peoples collection equity, limited ways on how to get them, fifty different borders.......I am worn out

moooooorreeeee stuffffff............

My issue is with how linear and easy setup these cards and shell were. Maybe they didnt think people would play Green? Its just kind of hard when you have the mana dork into Walker into counter protection (in green no less) into redraws. With a possible free refilter and a couple more pushed cards (...

Thats a lot of cards to look over.....

Mana Crypt, Meddling Mage, Path to Exile, Teferi's Protection, Teferi Temporal Archmage..................

OMG These are absolutely Horrible. Hope these people didnt have to actually spend money to get these .99 ebay bulk repacks

Im on the "How much money do they think we have train" Soooo many products along with all the normal stuff, plus Un stuff + Modern stuff + pioneer stuff probably coming. + theme boosters +planeswalker decks + really good BuyaBox + collectors packs + mythic edition + game night + challenger...

I run a Boros/Feather in Arena as well. A few differences...... Skynight Legionaires have won me so many games with the hasty fly over and a infuriate or other pump spell God's Willing is something I see in lots of decklists but I tend to run aggro/pump offensive and keep a creature or two in hand s...

The elephant in the room is............. is this the Only shell to play if you want to win

I kinda hope that Super Janky decks can have a somewhat competitive place in this new format. It could be super fun.