It would only work if there were sanctioning, prizes, and Wizards or an adjacent committee overseeing the banned list.
As is, cEDH is fine and a pre-game talk. Just inform what your deck does and your plan and people can decide on playing with you.
Search found 22 matches
- 1 year ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: Should cEDH spin off into its own format?
- Replies: 52
- Views: 2341
- 1 year ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: Is White getting better?
- Replies: 164
- Views: 11054
Re: Is White getting better?
White is getting better but it is still far, far too reliant on opponent synergies to gain its bonuses. This isn't too bad with something like Land Tax, where you get three lands before you draw, but having to wait until end step seems really slow. Archivist is more in line with what I want: immedia...
- 2 years ago
- Forum: Modern
- Topic: [Poll] Is your wallet fatigued in this format?
- Replies: 36
- Views: 12857
Re: [Poll] Is your wallet fatigued in this format?
I'm going to be the odd one here that says "no", and that's because I have been drifting out of Commander, which was a huge moneysink for me. By trading my Commander staples I've been able to get a ton of fetchlands, most of a Temur Rhinos deck and, with store credit, a good chunk of UW Co...
- 3 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: What are your aesthetic hang-ups?
- Replies: 58
- Views: 7285
Re: What are your aesthetic hang-ups?
Sweet thread, thanks for posting! Basic lands: From same expansion as Commander. For example, built Kambahl and the lands are from Kaladesh. Sigarda, Host of Herons had lands from her expansion. Why, because the mana comes from lands and they feel more comfortable on their own turf. Jasmine Boreal i...
- 3 years ago
- Forum: Decklists
- Topic: Jasmine Boreal - SHE'S BACK BABY - Critique my build,
- Replies: 2
- Views: 731
Jasmine Boreal - SHE'S BACK BABY - Critique my build,
] Commander 1 Jasmine Boreal Legendary creatures 1 Akroma, Angel of Wrath 1 Autumn Willow 1 Bruna, the Fading Light 1 Daughter of Autumn 1 Emiel the Blessed 1 Gabriel Angelfire 1 Gisela, the Broken Blade 1 God-Eternal Oketra 1 Kentaro, the Smiling Cat 1 Konda, Lord of Eiganjo 1 Lady Caleria 1 Sir Sh...
- 3 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: When a game ends up 1v1 - Gloves on or off?
- Replies: 46
- Views: 5143
Re: When a game ends up 1v1 - Gloves on or off?
Think once you are two players end it asap so we can start a new pod.
Prior, discuss power levels with your friends and go from there.
Prior, discuss power levels with your friends and go from there.
- 3 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: Power Level Model Discussion
- Replies: 15
- Views: 2488
Re: Power Level Model Discussion
I read it! I like where you went on the different axes of social play, construction, intent and time-to-win. These are all fantastic. I really, really liked that you used examples of players and their decks, how they built them and where they felt they fit on interaction scales. I'd like to see this...
- 3 years ago
- Forum: Rules and Philosophy
- Topic: If you could make one change in Commander...
- Replies: 111
- Views: 12699
Re: If you could make one change in Commander...
I'd honestly go with lowering the starting life total to 30, or 25, but 25 might be way, way too low. At 30, you would be at 25-24 after a few fetches/shockland entries, which is close enough to 20 that you would actually need to play with more spot removal, Wrath effect instead of just fishing for ...
- 3 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: Ban List Update - Flash Banned
- Replies: 193
- Views: 20881
Re: Ban List Update - Flash Banned
if4ko explained (finally) why there's not a cEDH stand-alone, it's due to card cost. I will say that our Duel Commander league has allowed proxies of Reserved List cards only for events under two conditions: 1)The card must be visibly identical to the original 2)The card must be valuable enough to p...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Rules and Philosophy
- Topic: If you could make one change in Commander...
- Replies: 111
- Views: 12699
Re: If you could make one change in Commander...
Partner no longer exists. Failing that, both Partners get commander taxed. That isn't going to happen, so I'll get loopy and suggest this: They should make cards that increase or decrease commander taxes. For example: Popeddy Popedda 3UW 2/4 Legendary Creature - Human Advisor. "While ~ is on th...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Rules and Philosophy
- Topic: Proxies in Commander
- Replies: 110
- Views: 19819
Re: Proxies in Commander
My philosophy on this hasn't really changes whether I have had a large collection or a smaller one (current). People should play with what they have, and we'll adjust our decks to that. As an example, prior to the illness, we had a person with the pre-con Ur-Dragon deck, my Jasmine Boreal jank, a Sa...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Rules and Philosophy
- Topic: SCD: Library of Alexandria
- Replies: 39
- Views: 8110
Re: SCD: Library of Alexandria
Obligatory warble nod where "You can't have Library banned if Tolarian Academy is banned. If Academy is too fast, then Library should be unbanned. l2b." Just because that post was...something else. That said, I don't really see this happening. It's super expensive and gives uninhibited car...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Rules and Philosophy
- Topic: [Speculation] Ban List Update Prediction Thread
- Replies: 200
- Views: 24882
Re: [Speculation] Ban List Update Prediction Thread
Rofellos should never come off. Umbral Mantle, Staff of Domination, etc. etc and in the color that will get more lands out, it's just too silly for words. As for next Monday's announcement, I'd say they go halfway and ban Protean Hulk again; that way Flash players can Flash Rector or other silliness...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: Lutri, the Spellchaser Preemptively Banned
- Replies: 210
- Views: 22368
Re: Lutri, the Spellchaser Preemptively Banned
I'm going to play Zirda maindeck in my Jor Kadeen Voltron. Getting that cost reduction is going to be amazing., especially if I can get Basalt Monolith out at some point.
Lurrus I am trying to build-around in Standard, with the new Benevolent Bodyguard and so on.
Lurrus I am trying to build-around in Standard, with the new Benevolent Bodyguard and so on.
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Previews
- Topic: FTV: Fetchlands (plus Chandra spellbook)
- Replies: 62
- Views: 7857
Re: FTV: Fetchlands (plus Chandra spellbook)
The fetches could also be in a December hype product or as a box topper of some sort for future Secret Lairs.
I'd be extremely doubtful of fetches in the CMDR product as they've never done this previously, and they are not super necessary to play CMDR unless you're cEDH.
I'd be extremely doubtful of fetches in the CMDR product as they've never done this previously, and they are not super necessary to play CMDR unless you're cEDH.
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Previews
- Topic: Mystery Booster Foils
- Replies: 21
- Views: 2902
Re: Mystery Booster Foils
Oh man Lantern of Insight and Codex Shredder is some of the most fun I've ever had playing Magic. Having them in foil is a win, not a big win like Chimney Imp and Storm Crow, but damned nice.
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: Power creep in the command zone - interesting article
- Replies: 58
- Views: 7969
Re: Power creep in the command zone - interesting article
IDK. My buddy showed up with his Chulane deck and he had Momir and Avenger and stuff in it but it wasn't super obnoxious, I just Vesiuvaned his Seedborn Muse and durdled a bit while the Mogis player ate our life away and the Sisay5C player did bomby stuff. It was fun, because we agreed to do cool st...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: What factors go into rating your deck?
- Replies: 39
- Views: 4604
Re: What factors go into rating your deck?
Good convo going on, love it. So when I build a deck my primary concerns are: A)Do I want to win? B)How much fun should my opponents have? I define "fun" as interactivity, using the combat step, and everyone getting to do stuff. My self-ratings: Jasmine Boreal: 0-2 on desire to win, it's t...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Rules and Philosophy
- Topic: Topical Discussion of the Official Multiplayer Ban List
- Replies: 194
- Views: 54614
Re: Topical Discussion of the Official Multiplayer Ban List
Bribery is fine if your meta has as bunch of jank in their decks. If everyone is running Kiki/Blightsteel etc it's more noxious, but at least it breaks their combo. Against the combined 21 from Partners, stuff like Bruse Tarl would just get crazy. If there's an internal discussion, please let it als...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: Secret Lair
- Replies: 55
- Views: 6402
Re: Secret Lair
Not really a fan of them or the speed of the releases, though the Thalia one was very, very tempting.
I'd rather just wait for Commander Legends or whatnot, there might be some sweet adds for my new Jor Kadeen deck.
I'd rather just wait for Commander Legends or whatnot, there might be some sweet adds for my new Jor Kadeen deck.
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: "Quirks That Define Your EDH Style"
- Replies: 59
- Views: 24902
Re: "Quirks That Define Your EDH Style"
1)As few mana rocks/ramp as possible. Sol ring, a Signet or two and maybe Explosive Veg and Reach and that's it; 2)Always have a "Fog" effect; 3)Play 6-8 cards that sweep the board, and 1-3 ways to recycle them. 4)Always build on a theme. Just to add to this, I'm playing Jor Kadeen soon an...
- 4 years ago
- Forum: Commander
- Topic: What's your most unusual commander and/or deck?
- Replies: 88
- Views: 67591
Re: What's your most unusual commander and/or deck?
Jasmine Boreal Peacekeeping/Nature-Wildernesss theme. "Peace must prevail, even if the wicked must die", . It has paladins, Peacekeeper , Peace Talks , Temporary Truce , Brisela Meld, a bunch of knights, it's just fair Magic for the most part. People are always cracking on me for having a...